Three Accounts of Peterloo by Eyewitnesses: Bishop Stanley, Lord Hylton, John Benjamin Smith; with Bishop Stanley's Evidence at the TrialStanley, Edward
History
Three Accounts of Peterloo by Eyewitnesses: Bishop Stanley, Lord Hylton, John Benjamin Smith; with Bishop Stanley's Evidence at the Trial
Stanley, Edward
Manchester (England) -- History; Peterloo Massacre, Manchester, England, 1819
Did it occur to your mind at the time that the cavalry were sent for
(because you went back to a window, and saw the messenger crossing the
field, for the purpose of bringing them to the place, and were told or
heard there was a rumour in the room above, that the cavalry had been
sent for) did it occur (attend to my question) to you, at the time, from
the observations which you had made on the subject, that that step was
improper or premature?--I don't think it occurred to me either one way or
the other.
Am I to understand from that then that you exercised no judgment upon the
subject at that time?--I certainly did exercise some judgment, some
opinion on it, at that time.
Having exercised some judgment upon the subject, I ask you whether, in
your judgment, such as you exercised upon that point, the step was either
improper or premature?--I saw no necessity for it.
Then you deemed it premature?--I saw no necessity for it.
It struck you then as an unnecessary act?--Certainly.
Then you would go down, of course, immediately and speak to your friend
upon the subject?--No.
Nor ever expressed to that friend or to any other, at the time, your
opinion with respect to the impropriety of the step?--I had no other
friend to speak to.
Did you speak to him?--I did not go down into the room again.
Probably you might, being a gentleman of considerable acquaintance, meet
with some friend on going home, and might ride home with some gentleman,
at least part of the road?--Part of the road I did.
Mr Markland, I presume?--I overtook Mr. Markland.
Did you express any opinion to Mr. Markland upon these
proceedings?--Probably I did; but I have not the most distant
recollection.
I ask you, upon your oath, Mr. Stanley, if you did not express to him your
entire concurrence in, and approbation of, the measures adopted by the
magistrates?--I answer, upon my oath, that I do not recollect having said
any such thing.
Can you tell me whether you expressed any disapprobation of the measures
which it had been deemed necessary to adopt?--I have no recollection
whatever of the conversation.
Then you mean to represent to us now, that your feelings upon the subject
were so indifferent, that you cannot tell now, whether you approved or
disapproved of these steps at the time?--I have not the most distant
recollection of any conversation I had with Mr. Markland.
That is not an answer to my question. I ask you whether you mean to state
that at this time, you don't remember whether you entertained feelings of
approbation or disapprobation of those steps?--I thought it was a dreadful
occurrence; but I hoped that there were some grounds for it.
Mr. JUSTICE HOLROYD: You are speaking of what you thought?--It was in
answer to the question.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account