Those who believe most firmly in democracy acknowledge, nevertheless,
that it has many objections, both in theory and in practice. Universal
suffrage--the abandoning of the state to the caprice of millions of
voters, among whom the proportion of intelligence to ignorance is
as one to ten--seems a process worthy of Bedlam. The ballot-box is
hardly more accurate than the dice-box, as a test of the fitness of
candidates. Popular government means party government, and parties
are dogmatic, overbearing, insincere, and corrupt. The men who
legislate and administer, chosen by this method, avowedly serve their
party, and not the state; and though, by chance, they should be both
skilful and honest, they may be overturned by a sudden revulsion
of the popular will. Such a system breeds a class of professional
politicians,--men who make a business of getting into office, and
whose only recommendation is their proficiency in the art of cajoling
voters. A government should be managed as a great business corporation
is managed: it has to deal with the weightiest problems of finance,
and with delicate diplomatic questions, for which the trained efforts
of judicious experts are needed; but instead of being intrusted to
them, it is given over to politicians elected by multitudes who cannot
even conduct their private business successfully, much less entertain
large and patriotic views of the common welfare. To decide an election
by a show of hands seems not a whit less absurd than to decide it
by the aggregate weight or the color of the hair of the voters. We
speak of the will of the majority as if it were infallibly right. The
vast majority of men to-day would vote that the sun revolves round
the earth: should this belief of a million ignoramuses countervail
the knowledge of one astronomer? Shall knowledge be the test of
fitness in all concerns except government, the most critical, the
most far-reaching and responsible of all? Majority rule substitutes
mere numbers, bulk, and quantity for quality. Putting a saddle on
Intelligence, it bids Ignorance mount and ride whither it will,--even
to the devil. It is the dupe of its own folly; for the politicians whom
it chooses turn out to be, not the representatives of the people, but
the attorneys of some mill or mine or railway.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account