Tom Watson's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 4, June 1905Various
General
Tom Watson's Magazine, Vol. I, No. 4, June 1905
Various
United States -- Politics and government -- Periodicals
The Constitution itself was modeled by delegates chosen, not by
citizens of the United States, _acting as individuals composing the
entire nation_, but by voters acting as _citizens composing distinct
and independent states to which they respectively belonged_. When the
completed Constitution was referred back to the people for adoption, it
was not acted upon by them as citizens of the entire nation, but it was
ratified by each state, acting as a state, separate and distinct from
every other state. _Therefore the Constitution itself is the result, not
of a national, but of a Federal act._
Mr. Madison himself took this ground in _The Federalist_. The facts all
prove it.
In the exercise of its legislative powers the Federal Government is both
national and Federal. The House of Representatives is a national body,
because it is composed of members chosen according to population. The
Senate is a Federal body, because it is chosen by the states, acting as
states.
The executive department of our Government also combines in itself both
the national and the Federal features.
The Electoral College is composed of two messengers from each state, and
also of messengers equal in number to the members which the state has in
the House of Representatives.
The two messengers first mentioned correspond with the two Senators,
and therefore represent the state in its Federal capacity. The other
messengers correspond with the Representatives of the state in the Lower
House, and as the Lower House is national, so those messengers are
national.
If the people fail to elect a President, and the election is thrown into
the House of Representatives, _this House, which in its organization as
a legislative body is national, at once becomes Federal, because each
state has one vote, and the voice of Ohio or Pennsylvania is not more
potent than that of Rhode Island or Delaware_.
It is only when our Government comes to put its laws into operation that
it is purely national.
It is not strictly correct, politically or legally, to say that the
United States is a nation, for a nation does not properly exist when the
Government is one of limited power. That our Government is one of limited
power, absolute only within the sphere of action granted to it by the
states, cannot be denied. While secession has been forever decided as not
being among the reserved rights of the states, there are very many other
reserved rights which still belong to the states, and which always should
be retained.
As the Washington _Post_ remarked some time since: “The United States
has not a single voter, and does not hold elections for any office. _All
elections are state elections._”
Already there has been too much concentration of power in the central
Government. To take away from the states their power of selecting
Senators would be nothing short of revolution, and would lead to such a
consolidation of power as would entirely change the form and spirit of
our Government.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account