Towards an enduring peace : $b A symposium of peace proposals and programs 1914-1916
History
Towards an enduring peace : $b A symposium of peace proposals and programs 1914-1916
Peace; World War, 1914-1918 -- Peace
It will be observed that the members of the league are not to bind
themselves to enforce the decision of the tribunal or the award of the
council of conciliation. That may come in the remote future, but it is
no part of this proposal. It would be imposing obligations far greater
than the nations can reasonably be expected to assume at the present day;
for the conceptions of international morality and fair play are still
so vague and divergent that a nation can hardly bind itself to wage war
on another, with which it has no quarrel, to enforce a decision or a
recommendation of whose justice or wisdom it may not be itself heartily
convinced. The proposal goes no further than obliging all the members
to prevent, by a threat of immediate war, any breach of the public
peace before the matter in dispute has been submitted to arbitration;
and this is neither unreasonable nor impracticable. There are many
questions, especially of a non-justiciable nature, on which we should not
be willing to bind ourselves to accept the decision of an arbitration,
and where we should regard compulsion by armed intervention of the rest
of the world as outrageous. Take, for example, the question of Asiatic
immigration, or a claim that the Panama Canal ought to be an unfortified
neutral highway, or the desire by a European Power to take possession
of Colombia. But we ought not, in the interest of universal peace, to
object to making a public statement of our position in these matters at a
court or council before resorting to arms; and in fact the treaty between
the United States and England, ratified on November 14, 1914, provides
that all disputes between the high contracting parties, of every nature
whatsoever, shall, failing other methods of adjustment, be referred for
investigation and report to a permanent international commission, with a
stipulation that neither country shall declare war or begin hostilities
during such investigation and before the report is submitted.
[Sidenote: Would not mean cession of sovereignty.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account