Towards an enduring peace : $b A symposium of peace proposals and programs 1914-1916
History
Towards an enduring peace : $b A symposium of peace proposals and programs 1914-1916
Peace; World War, 1914-1918 -- Peace
social advance beyond the limits we have already reached, but even of any
fundamental reconstruction of what the war will have destroyed.
Perhaps we might have foretold this from the case of Ireland immediately
under our eyes. Failure to solve her national problem has arrested
Ireland’s development since the seventeenth century, and imprisoned her
in a world of ideas almost unintelligible to an Englishman till he has
traveled in the Balkans. This has been England’s fault, and we are now
at last in a fair way to remedy it. The moment we have succeeded in
arranging that the different national groups in Ireland govern themselves
in the way they really wish, the national question will pass from the
Irish consciousness; they will put two centuries behind them at one
leap, and come into line with ourselves. The Dublin strike, contemporary
with the arming of the Volunteers, shows how the modern problems are
jostling at the heels of the old. Although “Unionist” and “Nationalist”
politicians could still declare that their attitude towards the strike
was neutral, the parliament of the new Irish state will discuss the
social problem and nothing else.
[Sidenote: Nationality is subjective not material.]
Ireland, then, has forced us to think about the problem of nationalism;
and our Irish experience will be invaluable to us when peace is made,
and we take in hand, in concert with our allies, the national questions
of the rest of Europe. To begin with, we already have a notion of what
Nationality is. Like all great forces in human life, it is nothing
material or mechanical, but a subjective psychological feeling in living
people. This feeling can be kindled by the presence of one or several of
a series of factors: a common country, especially if it is a well defined
physical region, like an island, a river basin, or a mountain mass; a
common language, especially if it has given birth to a literature; a
common religion; and that much more impalpable force, a common tradition
or sense of memories shared from the past.
[Sidenote: “Historical sentiment” is largely factitious.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account