Debate as to the admissibility of Ainslie, 111 Objection to Witness repelled, 115 Ainslie’s evidence, 115 Objection to production of Five-pound Note, 119 Objection sustained, 121 27. John Brown, _alias_ Humphry Moore, called, 122 Debate as to the admissibility of Brown, 122 Objection to Witness repelled, 132 Brown’s evidence, 132 Declarations of George Smith, 138 Declaration of William Brodie, 149 Letter, William Brodie to Matthew Sheriff, 150 Two Letters, William Brodie to Michael Henderson, 152 Copy Letter or Unsigned Scroll, No. I., 154 Copy Letter or Unsigned Scroll, No. II., 156 Account or State of William Brodie’s affairs, 158 Letter, Lee, Strachan & Co., to Emmanuel Walker & Co., 159 _Evidence for Defence._ 1. Matthew Sheriff, 160 2. Jean Watt, 161 3. Peggy Giles, 162 4. Helen Alison or Wallace, 163 5. James Murray, 164 6. James Laing, 164 7. Robert Smith, 164 The Lord Advocate’s Address to the Jury, 165 Mr. John Clerk’s Address to the Jury, 174 The Dean of Faculty’s Address to the Jury, 181 The Lord Justice-Clerk’s Charge to the Jury, 197 SECOND DAY--THURSDAY, 28TH AUGUST, 1788. Verdict of the Jury, 201 Plea in Arrest of Judgment, 202 Plea repelled, 208 Address to the Prisoners and Sentence, 209 APPENDICES. I. Notes on the Trial of Deacon Brodie, 211 II. A brief Account of the Judges and Counsel engaged on the Trial of Deacon Brodie, 217 III. A List of Publications on the Subject of or having Reference to the Trial of Deacon Brodie, 232 IV. The Brodie Family Bible, 238 V. Excerpts from the Records of the Cape Club, 243