"What shall I be?" she returned quietly. "The ignorant but beautiful
barbarian? A clothes horse slightly incapable of holding an intelligent
conversation? This seldom works, Scyth. I've studied history a bit and
I recall the case of a native girl called Pocahontas who was carried
from her native surroundings into the height of the civilization for
the time. She was no actress--she was _exhibited_ like a pet monkey or
a rare zoölogical specimen. She died of what they called heartbreak.
I think heartbreak in this case was a combination of loneliness, of
facing the realization that she could never really belong to the
culture, of the futility of asking to be returned to her people. In
other words Pocahontas lost the will to live. So thank you, Scyth, but
I have no desire to be a chattel, or a curiosity.... Or a museum-piece."
Scyth nodded seriously. "I see your point. But I don't agree with you.
In the first place you are indulging in a conversation with me. In the
second place, you--"
"In the first place," said Barbara pointedly, "this conversation is
being carefully kept on my level, isn't it?"
"I wouldn't say that."
"Of course not. But look, Scyth, aren't you using that menslator of
yours?"
"Of course."
"Then the menslator keeps the conversation down to my level because
by its very nature it cannot convey an idea to me that is beyond my
understanding. Am I correct?"
"In a sense, yes. But--"
"Scyth, can you menslate a dog, for instance?"
"A dog has so little mind that--"
Barbara interrupted this with a wave of her hand. "So how long would it
be before you and your people became damned sick and tired of talking
down? It would be like trying to conduct an adult discussion in baby
talk, wouldn't it?"
Scyth shook his head. "Not entirely," he said. "It might be that way
at first. But this would not last. I don't know of your history, but
I assume that your Pocahontas was a true savage. You had nothing like
the menslator. Doubtless she never learned any real language and so
lacked the ability to use a language of any kind, let alone learn the
ramifications of the culture behind it. You would be on an entirely
different plane. You have a language and a culture and you are quick to
grasp a new idea. With a menslator you would learn the language well
enough in a short time and while the deeper factors of the culture
would always escape you, the superficial parts would eventually come
easy."
* * * * *
For an answer, Barbara pointed to the wall. "Scyth, on that wall is a
painting given to me by a character who calls himself an artist. Take a
gander."
Scyth looked. The painting was a mess of squiggles and blots of color.
It was iridescent here and drab there, soft lines elsewhere and sharp
contrasts somewhere else.
"Interesting," said Scyth. "What is it?"
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account