American essays -- 20th century; State, The; World War, 1914-1918
Vision must constantly outshoot technique, opportunist efforts usually
achieve less even than what seemed obviously possible. An impossibilist
élan that appeals to desire will often carry further. A philosophy of
adjustment will not even make for adjustment. If you try merely to
“meet” situations as they come, you will not even meet them. Instead
you will only pile up behind you deficits and arrears that will some
day bankrupt you.
We are in the war because an American Government practiced a philosophy
of adjustment, and an instrumentalism for minor ends, instead of
creating new values and setting at once a large standard to which the
nations might repair. An intellectual attitude of mere adjustment,
of mere use of the creative intelligence to make your progress, must
end in caution, regression, and a virtual failure to effect even that
change which you so clear-sightedly and desirously see. This is the
root of our dissatisfaction with much of the current political and
social realism that is preached to us. It has everything good and wise
except the obstreperous vision that would drive and draw all men into
it.
IV
The working-out of this American philosophy in our intellectual life
then has meant an exaggerated emphasis on the mechanics of life at the
expense of the quality of living. We suffer from a real shortage of
spiritual values. A philosophy that worked when we were trying to get
that material foundation for American life in which more impassioned
living could flourish no longer works when we are faced with inexorable
disaster and the hysterias of the mob. The note of complacency which
we detect in the current expressions of this philosophy has a bad
taste. The congruous note for the situation would seem to be, on the
contrary, that of robust desperation,--a desperation that shall rage
and struggle until new values come out of the travail, and we see
some glimmering of our democratic way. In the creation of these new
values, we may expect the old philosophy, the old radicalism, to be
helpless. It has found a perfectly definite level, and there is no
reason to think that it will not remain there. Its flowering appears
in the technical organization of the war by an earnest group of young
liberals, who direct their course by an opportunist programme of
State-socialism at home and a league of benevolently imperialistic
nations abroad. At their best they can give us a government by prudent,
enlightened college men instead of by politicians. At their best,
they can abolish war by making everybody a partner in the booty of
exploitation. That is all, and it is technically admirable. Only there
is nothing in the outlook that touches in any way the happiness of
the individual, the vivifying of the personality, the comprehension
of social forces, the flair of art,--in other words, the quality of
life. Our intellectuals have failed us as value-creators, even as
value-emphasizers. The allure of the martial in war has passed only
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account