American essays -- 20th century; State, The; World War, 1914-1918
There is nothing fixed about the objects to which society demands
conformity. It is only the quantity that seems to be constant. So much
conformity, like the conservation of physical energy in the universe,
but the manners in which people shall think alike, or behave, or what
objects they shall consider sacred, differ in myriad ways throughout
different social groupings and in different eras. Diametrically
opposite ideas are held in two social groups with the same vigor and
fury; diametrically opposite conduct is considered equally praiseworthy
and necessary; two social groups will visit with the same punishment
two diametrically opposite actions. To any student of primitive
societies or of the history of Western civilization, these facts are
commonplaces. But the moral is not a commonplace as yet. Yet it must
be evident that most of the customs and attitudes of these societies
were almost wholly irrational, that is, they were social habits which
persisted solely through inertia and the satisfaction they gave the
gregarious impulse. The latter had to be satisfied, so that anything
which cost the least in invention or reasoning or effort would do. The
customs, therefore, of primitive tribes seem to practically everybody
in a modern Western society outlandish and foolish. What evidence is
there that our codes and conformities which perform exactly the same
rôle, and are mostly traditional survivals, are any the less outlandish
and irrational? May they not be tainted with the same purposelessness?
Is not the inference irresistible that they are? They seem to us to
be intelligent and necessary not because we have derived them or
invented them for a clearly imagined and desired end, but because they
satisfy our need for acting in a herd, just as the primitive savage is
satisfied.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account