Vaccination a Delusion: Its Penal Enforcement a Crime: Proved by the Official Evidence in the Reports of the Royal Commission — John Shaqi
Vaccination a Delusion: Its Penal Enforcement a Crime: Proved by the Official Evidence in the Reports of the Royal CommissionWallace, Alfred Russel
Science
Vaccination a Delusion: Its Penal Enforcement a Crime: Proved by the Official Evidence in the Reports of the Royal Commission
Wallace, Alfred Russel
Vaccination
The Commissioners repeatedly call attention to the fact that the
mortality from measles has not at all declined and that other zymotics
have not declined in the same proportion as small-pox, and they argue:
“If improved sanitary conditions were the cause of small-pox becoming
less, we should expect to see that they had exercised a similar influence
over almost all other diseases. Why should they not produce the same
effect in the case of measles, scarlet fever, whooping-cough, and indeed
any disease spread by contagion or infection and from which recovery
was possible?” This seems a most extraordinary position to be taken in
view of the well-known disappearance of various diseases at _different_
epochs. Why did leprosy almost disappear from England at so early a
period and plague later on? Surely to _some_ improved conditions of
health. The Commissioners do not, and we may presume cannot, tell us
why measles, of all the zymotic diseases, has rather increased than
diminished during the whole of this century. Many students of epidemics
hold that certain diseases are liable to replace each other, as suggested
by Dr. Watt, of Glasgow, in the case of measles and small-pox. Dr.
Farr, the great medical statistician, adopted this view. In his Annual
Report to the Registrar-General in 1872 (p. 224), he says: “The zymotic
diseases replace each other; and when one is rooted out it is apt to be
replaced by others which ravage the human race indifferently whenever
the conditions of healthy life are wanting. They have this property
in common with weeds and other forms of life: as one species recedes
another advances.” This last remark is very suggestive in view of the
modern germ-theory of these diseases. This substitution theory is
adopted by Dr. Creighton, who in his _History of Epidemics in England_
suggests that plague was replaced by typhus fever and small-pox; and,
later on, measles, which was insignificant before the middle of the
seventeenth century, began to replace the latter disease. In order
to show the actual state of the mortality from these diseases during
the epoch of registration, I have prepared a diagram (II.) giving the
death-rates for London of five of the chief zymotics, from the returns
of the Registrar-General, under the headings he adopted down to 1868—for
to divide fevers into three kinds for half the period, and to separate
scarlatina and diphtheria, as first done in 1859, would prevent any
useful comparison from being made.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account