Villainage in England: Essays in English Mediaeval HistoryVinogradoff, Paul
History
Villainage in England: Essays in English Mediaeval History
Vinogradoff, Paul
Villeinage -- England -- History -- To 1500
Gneist's work is somewhat different in colouring and closely connected
with a definite political theory. Tocqueville in France has done most to
draw attention to the vital importance of local self-government in the
development of liberal institutions; and Stubbs' history goes far to
demonstrate Tocqueville's general view by a masterly statement as to the
origins of English institutions. In Gneist's hands the doctrine of
decentralisation assumes a particular shape by the fact that it is
constructed on a social foundation; the German thinker has been trying
all along to show that the English influence is not one of
self-government only, but of aristocratical self-government. The part
played by the gentry in local and central affairs is the great point of
historical interest in Gneist's eyes. Even in the Saxon period he lays
stress chiefly on the early rise of great property, and the great
importance of 'Hlafords' in social organisation. He pays no attention to
the village community, and chiefly cares for the landlord. But still
even Gneist admits the original personal freedom of the great mass of
the people, and his analysis of the English condition is based on the
assumption, that it represents one variation of Teutonic development:
this gives Gneist a place among the Germanists, although his views on
particular subjects differ from those of other scholars of the same
school.[23]
[The Mark system.]
Its chief representatives have acquired such a celebrity that it is
hardly necessary to insist again, that excellent work has been done by
them for the study of the past. But the direction of their work has been
rather one-sided; it was undertaken either from the standpoint of
political institutions or from that of general culture and external
growth; the facts of agriculture, of the evolution of classes, of legal
organisation were touched upon only as subsidiary to the main objects of
general history. And yet, even from the middle of the century, the
attention of Europe begins to turn towards those very facts. The
'masses' come up with their claims behind the 'classes,' the social
question emerges in theory and in practice, in reform and revolution;
Liberals and Conservatives have to reckon with the fact that the great
majority of the people are more excited, and more likely to be moved by
the problems of work and wages than by problems of political influence.
The everlasting, ever-human struggle for power gets to be considered
chiefly in the light of the distribution of wealth; the distribution of
society into classes and conditions appears as the connecting link
between the economical process and the political process. This great
change in the aspect of modern life could not but react powerfully on
the aspect of historical literature. G.F. von Maurer and Hanssen stand
out as the main initiators of the new movement in our studies. The many
volumes devoted by G.F. Maurer[24] to the village and the town of
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account