New York (N.Y.) -- Social life and customs -- Fiction; Wall Street (New York, N.Y.) -- Fiction
“Make out a check for $35,000 payable to Mrs. Rose Hunt, and transfer
the 100 Manhattan Electric Light 5s to my personal account.”
He gave her the check and told her: “Here is the money. I am very sorry
that I unwittingly caused you some anxiety. But all’s well that ends
well. Any time that I can be of service to you—Not at all. Don’t thank
me, please; no. Good morning.”
But he did not tell her that by taking over her account he paid $96,000
for bonds he could have bought in the open market for $93,000. He was
the politest man in Wall Street; and, after all, he had known Hunt for
many years.
A week later Manhattan Electric 5–per cent bonds sold at 96 again. Mrs.
Hunt called on him. It was noon, and she evidently had spent the morning
mustering up courage for the visit. They greeted one another, she
embarrassed and he courteous and kindly as usual.
“Mr. Colwell, you still have those bonds, haven’t you?”
“Why, yes.”
“I—I think I’d like to take them back.”
“Certainly, Mrs. Hunt. I’ll find out how much they are selling for.” He
summoned a clerk to get a quotation on Manhattan Electric 5s. The clerk
telephoned to one of their bond-specialists, and learned that the bonds
could be bought at 96½. He reported to Mr. Colwell, and Mr. Colwell told
Mrs. Hunt, adding: “So you see they are practically where they were when
you bought them before.”
She hesitated. “I—I—didn’t you buy them from me at 93? I’d like to buy
them back at the same price I sold them to you.”
“No, Mrs. Hunt,” he said; “I bought them from you at 96.”
“But the price was 93.” And she added, corroboratively: “Don’t you
remember it was in all the papers?”
“Yes, but I gave you back exactly the same amount that I received from
you, and I had the bonds transferred to my account. They stand on our
books as having cost me 96.”
“But couldn’t you let me have them at 93?” she persisted.
“I’m very sorry, Mrs. Hunt, but I don’t see how I could. If you buy them
in the open market now, you will be in exactly the same position as
before you sold them, and you will make a great deal of money, because
they are going up now. Let me buy them for you at 96½.”
“At 93, you mean,” with a tentative smile.
“At whatever price they may be selling for,” he corrected, patiently.
“Why did you let me sell them, Mr. Colwell?” she asked, plaintively.
“But, my dear madam, if you buy them now, you will be no worse off than
if you had kept the original lot.”
“Well, I don’t see why it is that I have to pay 96½ now for the very
same bonds I sold last Tuesday at 93. If it was some other bonds,” she
added, “I wouldn’t mind so much.”
“My dear Mrs. Hunt, it makes no difference which bonds you hold. They
have all risen in price, yours and mine and everybody’s; your lot was
the same as any other lot. You see that, don’t you?”
“Ye-es; but——”
“Well, then, you are exactly where you were before you bought any.
You’ve lost nothing, because you received your money back intact.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account