Ellice Winsloe was silent. I saw as he stood back in the shadow from the table that his brows had contracted and that he was pensive and puzzled. And yet upstairs in his bag he had a portrait of the dead man, and was, therefore, well aware of his identity. Now that we reflected we agreed that we really knew very little of Ellice Winsloe. He was Jack's friend rather than ours. The son of a Cornishman whose income was derived from his interest in certain tin mines, he had, on his father's death, been left well off. Jack had known him at Magdalen, but had lost sight of him for some years, when of a sudden they met again one night while at supper at the Savoy, and their old friendship had been renewed. Ellice, it appeared, was well known in a certain set in town, and up to the present moment we had both voted him as a good all-round sportsman, a good fellow and a gentleman. But this secret knowledge which he refused to betray, and his evident fear lest the dead man be identified, aroused our serious suspicions. "I wonder," suggested Eric, when we were alone in my room on the night of the inquest, "I wonder whether Ellice was in hiding in those bushes watching us search the body? Do you know, the idea has been in my mind all day," he added. "If he was, then we are placed in a very awkward position," I said. "He may make a statement to the police." "No. I don't think he'll do that. If he did he would betray his own knowledge," was my friend's answer. The next day passed uneventfully, and beyond the general surprise at Tibbie's continued absence there was nothing unusual in the household at Ryhall Place. Late that night Mason returned, saying that her mistress had driven the car to the Bath Hotel, at Bournemouth, and put it into the garage. Three hours later she left the hotel to go for a walk, but did not return. After she had gone the maid had, it seemed, found a letter in which her mistress ordered her to remain there until Wednesday, and telling her that if she did not return then she was to go back to Ryhall and send the chauffeur to Bournemouth for the car. Mason, used to Tibbie's erratic ways, thought little of it. Her mistress travelled a great deal, had a very large circle of friends, and besides, was entirely unconventional and knew well how to take care of herself. Therefore the maid had remained until midday on Wednesday and then returned to Ryhall. "I'm getting a little anxious about Tibbie," remarked old Lady Scarcliff in the drawing-room that evening. "This kind of thing is not at all proper--flying about the country alone." Jack laughed. "No good worrying about Tibbie, mater. She'll turn up all right to-morrow, or you'll get a wire from her. You remember that time she met the Hursts in Nice and went off yachting with them down the Mediterranean, and we didn't know where she was for three weeks. And then she calmly said she'd quite forgotten to tell us where she was going."