When You Don't Know Where to Turn: A Self-Diagnosing Guide to Counseling and TherapyBartlett, Steven J.
Science
When You Don't Know Where to Turn: A Self-Diagnosing Guide to Counseling and Therapy
Bartlett, Steven J.
Consumer education; Counseling; Psychotherapy
This happens in several ways. For example, paying attention to a
person increases his morale and self-esteem. This is called the
_Hawthorne effect_. "Anyone who has been in therapy can appreciate the
gratification that comes from having a competent professional give
undivided attention for an hour."[16] Also, the expectation on the
part of a therapist that positive results will follow itself can
influence a client's attitudes and his belief that he will get better,
that emotional suffering will lessen and end.
[16] James O. Prochaska, _Systems of Psychotherapy: A Transtheoretical
Analysis_ (Homewood, IL: The Dorsey Press, 1979), p. 5.
The strength of a client's _belief_ that he _can_ change, that he _can_
improve, is the major single force in psychotherapy. The client has to
feel that his belief is _warranted_. Many factors play a role here:
the client's education level and the respect he may feel toward the
therapist's training and experience; the intangibles of therapy--the
therapist's integrity, authenticity or convincingness, the client's
sense that he is understood, that the therapist cares, that the
therapist himself has learned how to cope with living and can
communicate this, etc. Psychotherapy can be successful when this sense
of _promise_ is present in therapy sessions.
CLIENTS LOOK BACK
I know myself better than any doctor can.
Ovid
If most emotional difficulties are not illnesses at all but problems of
living, and if problems of living cannot be treated medically, then the
hundreds of evaluative studies of therapeutic effectiveness have been
looking for something that simply is not there: an objective standard
against which to judge therapeutic {277} success. It makes very little
sense to speak of standards in connection with problems of living that
come about from demoralization. The only standard we can reasonably
appeal to is the subjective judgment of clients themselves, who have
experienced periods in therapy.
[Therapy] is a purely individual affair and can be measured only in
terms of its meaning to the person, child, or adult, of its value,
not for happiness, not for virtue, not for social adjustment but
for growth and development in terms of a purely individual norm.[17]
[17] J. Taft, _The Dynamics of Therapy in a Controlled Relationship_
(New York: Macmillan, 1933), quoted in H. H. Mosak, "Problems in the
Definition and Measurement of Success in Psychotherapy," in Wolff and
Precker, eds., _Success in Psychotherapy_, p. 7.
A few representative and specific evaluations of their experiences in
psychotherapy by former clients follow. They are included here not as
proof of the effectiveness of psychotherapy, because to search for
objective proof in this area is a mistake, but rather as illustrations
of different ways people believe themselves to have been helped:[18]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account