When You Don't Know Where to Turn: A Self-Diagnosing Guide to Counseling and TherapyBartlett, Steven J.
Science
When You Don't Know Where to Turn: A Self-Diagnosing Guide to Counseling and Therapy
Bartlett, Steven J.
Consumer education; Counseling; Psychotherapy
This book is dedicated to Karen,
my love, wife, and friend.
Preface to the Project Gutenberg Edition
Nearly three decades have passed since _When You Don't Know Where to
Turn_ was first published. In that time, psychiatry, clinical
psychology, and counseling have changed a good deal.
Psychiatry has continued on a now well-worn path leading to a more and
more inflated universe of diagnostic labels, the majority of which have
no known organic basis. Few readers who are not themselves mental
health professionals realize that these diagnostic classifications are
_voted into existence_ by committees of psychiatrists whose
pronouncements magically summon into being a lengthening list of
so-called "mental disorders." These pronouncements are then applied to
people in order to label their problems (as well as the people who have
them), to match their problems with allegedly effective treatments, and
in the process to give the impression that a respectable medical
process of diagnosis and intervention has been undertaken.
And yet these so-called "mental disorders" do little more than equate
designated patterns of behavior, emotion, or thought--called
syndromes--with alleged psychological malfunctioning. Such syndromes
are no more than sets of symptoms that can be collected together in a
wide variety of different ways, but depending upon how they are
grouped, distinguishable syndromes can be pointed to and named. This is
a highly arbitrary process very much like fortune-telling using tea
leaves, which depends on the pattern seen or imagined in the tea leaves
at the bottom of a cup.
During the past three decades, clinical psychology and its less formal
cousin, counseling, have also undergone noticeable change. They have
been the traditional sources of a large number of diverse approaches to
psychotherapy and counseling. But in the past thirty years, the large
number of approaches to psychotherapy and counseling has, in practical
reality, shrunk considerably. This has been due to the rapid dominance
and virtual monopoly that has been gained by cognitive-behavioral
therapy, also known as rational-emotive therapy. Insurance companies
have been attracted like flies to the sweetness of the comparatively
brief treatment period touted by cognitive-behavioral therapy, and
practitioners have similarly been attracted by the ease of using its
one-size-fits-all approach.
And so where the changes in psychiatry have been inflationary in its
authorized catalogue of "mental disorders" known as the _DSM_
(_Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders_), clinical
psychology and counseling have been on a deflationary course that has
progressively narrowed the treatment options available to many people.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account