Why a National Literature Cannot Flourish in the United States of North AmericaRocchietti, Joseph
General
Why a National Literature Cannot Flourish in the United States of North America
Rocchietti, Joseph
American literature; United States -- Social life and customs
Mr. Headley is rather one of the most mild in his language, among the
many writers who, in copying each other, bring such an unjust blame on
all the italian ladies. There may be nations, where ladies might know
better how to conceal their affections; but, as the race of Adam and
Eve are all beings of flesh, blood, and bones, instances of depravity
are found in every part of the world; and like sins, stand in the
records of America as well as of Italy: and as there are gentlemen who
have their mother and sisters in Italy, whom they esteem and honor, I
would advise such writers to use a better language, when they write
of other nations. To speak disrespectfully of the ladies of a whole
nation, it is not a demonstration; and it is only the devil on two
sticks, who could be able to say so. A gentleman from the top of a
tower, cannot see what passes in the households of a strange country.
The writer of “Italy and the Italians;” after having passed three weeks
in the only city of Genoa, he reproaches himself by having mistook
an italian lady for a common woman, because she was badly dressed.
And because her good nature prevented her from resenting his innocent
mistake, by this only fact, he thinks that the ladies of Italy have not
the dignity of the american or english ladies. “Dignity and woman’s
rights,” says he, “are nothing to an italian lady, while victory
is every thing.” It seems to me that, had the italian lady pouted,
because of his mistake, such a bad humor would have robbed her of all
woman’s dignity, and woman’s right. Nothing is more attractive in a
woman than her innocent forgiveness. And the woman, who shows any fear
of losing her dignity or woman’s rights before a gentleman, she does
but tell him he is not a gentleman. However, had, here, the gentleman
been acquainted with her language, he might have discovered the lady
under servant’s garments; and her new dress, nothing but a reproach on
herself by having forgotten, at that moment, that she ought to have
been better dressed before them. There are faults in innocent woman,
which render her still more lovely. It is like that child who stumbles,
for too much eagerness in running to embrace its mother. I suppose she
was one of those good italian ladies, who forget themselves to please
their neighbors; and while her innocent blunders force you to love the
childish woman, who always places you at home, you find yourself happy
in playing the child with her. That which one calls woman’s dignity,
for another, is nothing but a chilling pride.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account