Why a National Literature Cannot Flourish in the United States of North America — John Shaqi
Why a National Literature Cannot Flourish in the United States of North AmericaRocchietti, Joseph
General
Why a National Literature Cannot Flourish in the United States of North America
Rocchietti, Joseph
American literature; United States -- Social life and customs
In writing against the present, fashionable style of ridiculing, I wish
to be well understood. I do not intend here, to dissuade writers from
exposing the ridicule of man in the abstract. On the contrary; I think,
for our improvements, nothing is more beneficial than the caricatures,
or the faults of real life, exposed in a ridiculous light, by which the
reader would correct his faults, if he has any like. But the writer
should give the caricatures with such modifications, or charged colors,
with which to avoid all personalities. And here, the writer, who must
pen from nature, may sometimes delineate a living character, whom he
had forgotten, or did never see: but, such a writer cannot be blamed
for all the faults of man; and as it is not a malicious composition,
he, who has like ridicules, has but to correct himself.
National faults also cannot be personalities. Besides, I may, for
instance, write, or speak of persons I met in a stage, in a private
house, theatre, or church, provided their names are not mentioned.
If the historical fact happened, only, with the person introduced in
the tale, nobody knows of whom the writer is speaking, or writing;
if it happened before other persons, the truth of the fact prevents,
rather, those fond of making false stories from the smallest event; the
truth cannot offend either of the parties. Besides, men would conduct
themselves better, were they afraid of being exposed: and if we have
committed an offence towards an innocent person, we should listen,
and do better for the time to come. I mean only to say here, were all
writers, who can wield a pen, permitted to book all the characters they
meet with, writers should be avoided as cholera: and though in this,
and many other countries libeling did turn fashionable, I understood
that such writers are not the most welcome, among those who do not
like to see their private characters heralded; and that America can
not be offended in finding american families heralded, because lords,
and ladies of England are heralded also, it is the same as to wish
here, the same faults, permitted in that country, for no other reason,
because the lords of England cannot prevent an english editor from
prying into their private houses. If I preach morals, and at the same
time I act immorally, not only I wrong myself in exposing my hypocrisy;
but, I turn literature into an infamous art. I repeat it again, good
or bad characters may be blended in a novel, comedy, or tragedy, where
the characters, though taken from nature, cannot offend any private
individual; but, the names, or exact characters, should not be exposed
by writers, unless the individuals are notorious, or had already become
a part of history.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account