Music -- Philosophy and aesthetics; Music -- Psychological aspects
Many persons who pass as musicians are neither temperamental nor
musical. A great many of those who ply the art of music do not have
musical minds in any basic sense. Their art consists in certain skills
often built into a purely matter-of-fact organism. I therefore see no
reason why such people in the musical world who do not show any artistic
temperament have any reason to boast of the fact.
The highly temperamental musician is a species of genius in some degree.
As such, he has been described by musicians, scientists, and
psychiatrists in a very copious body of literature on the subject,
especially that dating since the time of Lombroso, who regarded all
geniuses as degenerates. The modern psychiatrist has frequently
presented a picturesque view of the temperamental person in terms of the
rising science and art of psychiatry, which is supposed to explain all
deviations from normal behavior in terms of psychopathology. The old
saying was that we are all more or less sane; the psychiatrist today
says we are all more or less psychopathic. The current literature on
mental hygiene is characterized by this point of view. Another point of
view has proved fascinating since the coming in of Freud, in that
deviations of this sort are accounted for in terms of suppressions,
defense reactions, and other manifestations of the libido. Much light is
thrown on the problem by the great musician's exaltation of the artistic
mind in action, thus revealing essential temperamental traits on the
basis of first-hand experience and artistic theory. A temperamental
musician is the most merciless portrayer of his own species. Since the
temperamental person is always an interesting person, all of these
accounts are lively and each revealing from its own point of view,
giving us much genuine insight into the nature of the temperamental
person in all fields.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account