Wit and its relation to the unconsciousFreud, Sigmund
Science
Wit and its relation to the unconscious
Freud, Sigmund
Subconsciousness; Wit and humor -- Psychological aspects
“The same mechanism is found in the following: A dramatic critic,
summarizing three paragraphs to the effect that most plays now produced
in New York City are violently emotional and hysterical, remarks:
‘Thespis has taken up his home in Dramatteawan.’ The last word is a
condensation of _drama_ and _Matteawan_. The substitution not only
expressed the critic’s idea that most of the plays at present produced
in New York are violent, emotional and hysterical, that is insane, but
it also contains a clever allusion to the nature of the problem
presented by most of these plays. Matteawan is a state hospital for
criminal insane. Most of the plays are not only insane, but also
criminal since they treat of murders, divorces, robberies, scandals,
etc.”
When Flaubert published his famous romance _Salammbo_, which treats of
life in ancient Carthage, it was scoffingly referred to by Sainte-Beuve
as _Carthaginoiserie_ on account of its tedious detailed descriptions.
Carthaginoiserie
chinoiserie
During a conversation with a lady I unintentionally furnished the
material for a jest. I spoke to her about the great merits of an
investigator whom I considered unjustly ignored. She remarked, “But the
man really deserves a monument.” “Perhaps he will get one some day,” I
answered, “but at the moment his success is very limited.” “Monument”
and “moment” are contrasts. The lady then united these contrasts and
said: “Well, let us wish him a _monumentary_ success.”
If at this stage the reader should become displeased with a viewpoint
which threatens to destroy his pleasure in wit without explaining the
source of this pleasure I must beg him to be patient for a while,
because we are now confronted with the technique of wit, the examination
of which promises many revelations if only we enter into it far enough.
Besides the analysis of the examples thus far cited, which show simply a
process of condensation, there are others in which the changed
expressions manifest themselves in other ways.
_Condensation with Modification and Substitution_
The following witticisms of Mr. N. will serve as illustrations.
“I was driving with him tête-à-bête.” Nothing is simpler than the
reduction of this jest. Evidently it can only mean: I was driving
tête-à-tête with Mr. X. and X. is a stupid ass (beast).
Neither of these two sentences is witty nor is there any wit if one
combines them into this one: “I was out driving tête-à-tête with that
stupid ass (beast).” The wit appears when the words “stupid ass” are
omitted and when, as a substitute for them, the first “t” of the second
“tête” is changed to “b.” This slight modification brings back to
expression the suppressed “bête.” The technique of this group of
witticisms may be described as “condensation with a slight
modification.” And it would seem that the more insignificant the
substitutive modification, the better is the wit.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account