Wit and its relation to the unconsciousFreud, Sigmund
Science
Wit and its relation to the unconscious
Freud, Sigmund
Subconsciousness; Wit and humor -- Psychological aspects
_A similar comical story is the one which tells of a blacksmith in a
Hungarian village who has committed a crime punishable by death; the
bürgomaster, however, decreed that not the smith but a tailor was to be
hanged, as there were two tailors in the village but only one
blacksmith, and the crime had to be expiated._ Such a displacement of
guilt from one person to another naturally contradicts all laws of
conscious logic, but in no ways the mental trends of the unconscious. I
am in doubt whether to call this story comic, and still I put the story
of the kettle among the witticisms. Now I admit that it is far more
correct to designate the latter as comic rather than witty. But now I
understand how it happens that my feelings, usually so reliable, can
leave me in the lurch as to whether this story be comic or witty. The
case in which I cannot come to a conclusion through my feelings is the
one in which the comic results through the uncovering of modes of
thought which exclusively belong to the unconscious. A story of that
kind can be comic and witty at the same time; but it will impress me as
being witty even if it be only comic, because the use of the faulty
thinking of the unconscious reminds me of wit, just as in the case of
the arrangements for the uncovering of the hidden comic discussed before
(p. 325).
I must lay great stress upon making clear this most delicate point of my
analysis, namely, the relation of wit to the comic, and will therefore
supplement what has been said with some negative statements. First of
all, I call attention to the fact that the case of the meeting of wit
and comic treated here (p. 327) is not identical with the preceding one.
I grant it is a fine distinction, but it can be drawn with certainty. In
the preceding case the comic originated from the uncovering of the
psychic automatism. This is in no way peculiar to the unconscious alone
and it does not at all play a conspicuous part in the technique of wit.
Unmasking appears only accidentally in relation with wit, in that it
serves another technique of wit, namely, representation through the
opposite. But in the case of giving free play to unconscious ways of
thinking the union of wit and comic is an essential one, because the
same method which is used by the first person in wit as the technique of
releasing pleasure will naturally produce comic pleasure in the third
person.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account