With the GunsStreet, Cecil J. C. (Cecil John Charles)
History
With the Guns
Street, Cecil J. C. (Cecil John Charles)
World War, 1914-1918 -- Artillery operations, British; World War, 1914-1918 -- Personal narratives, British
upon the Tenth French Army, the first of that great chain of armies
that spreads, with one short gap, to the faraway Swiss mountains.
All through August and September the roads behind the Allied front
had been covered by infantry and artillery, and even towards the end
by cavalry, all moving eastwards through the all-pervading chalk dust.
Rumour, as ever, was busy with conjecture. This was merely a feint,
maintained the pessimists, the real advance is to lie with the French
in Champagne. Nonsense, replied the optimists, this is at last the
long-looked-for general advance, the death-blow of trench warfare, the
dawning of the millennium when the Battle of Position shall give way to
the Battle of Movement, the beginning of the final struggle that will
end only with the death-throes of the enemy on the Rhine! Whatever were
one's individual opinions, the scent of battle, the glorious prospect
of a "scrap," was in the air, and spirits rose accordingly.
Slowly, from the august sources wherein the strategy of armies has
its birth, the true intentions of the Allies percolated. Looking back
now, it seems that too much was allowed to be known from the first.
Documents containing detailed programmes of the proposed operations
were circulated in some cases as much as a fortnight before the
selected day, and in the field it is impossible to prevent the contents
of such documents becoming common knowledge within an incredibly
short time, which is practically equivalent to sending the originals
across to the enemy with one's compliments. It was subsequently
established by the examination of prisoners that the German General
Staff had full knowledge of our plans many days before the attack
took place, and had, indeed, made dispositions to meet it. It is
undoubtedly essential to circulate beforehand exact instructions as
to the part that each unit is to perform in contemplated operations,
but it is extremely doubtful if it is expedient to do so until the
last possible moment. Apart from the danger of leakage to the enemy,
it is always found, as indeed in this case, that the interval that
elapses between the receipt of instructions and their execution is
filled with a storm of amplifications, contradictions and amendments,
poured out by intermediate commanders, until the unfortunate commander
of a unit is faced, when called upon to act, by an accumulation of
mutually incompatible orders. If a strong man, he throws them all
indiscriminately into the fire, and, acting by the light of his own
commonsense and initiative, stands a fair chance of succeeding; if
a weak man, he endeavours to act upon them all, and, with deadly
certainty, fails.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account