Civic improvement; Urban women; Women in public life
The struggle over the superintendency and the policy of Chicago
public schools acutely emphasizes the crises which popular local
government must meet and turn for better or worse. Coming to the
superintendency four years ago in the most troublous times the
Chicago public schools had ever experienced, Mrs. Ella Flagg Young
brought the badly divided teachers into harmonious relations with
each other and with her management and secured an equally remarkable
unanimity in the public support of her administration, after a long
period of bitterly divisive discussion in the press and among the
people.
Within the Board of Education, however, whose twenty-one members
have never been able to agree very well with each other,
disagreements with Mrs. Young and her policies have come to the
surface, especially among the members of the board appointed by
Mayor Harrison. He protests his preference for her administration
and once before came to the support of her policies when she
tendered her resignation rather than surrender the superintendent’s
prerogative in the selection of textbooks. The mayor’s opposition to
the acceptance of her resignation then kept enough members of the
Board in line with her to warrant its withdrawal.
But the divisiveness of that controversy both widened and deepened
at many points of personal and administrative difference. Except the
two outspoken opponents, the other disaffected members of the board
combined their opposition in silence and secrecy. To the surprise of
the public, which the mayor, many members of the school board, and
even the opposition itself, claimed to share, Mrs. Young failed to
receive the eleven votes necessary for her reëlection. Ten members
voted for her, six against her, and four were recorded as “not
voting” in the secret ballot.
Mrs. Young immediately withdrew her name, claiming that no
superintendent can succeed who requires a second ballot for
election. The second ballot was taken at once, after reconsideration
of the first ballot was refused and John D. Shoop, first assistant
superintendent, was elected by a vote of eleven to five, without
discussion. The president of the board immediately resigned, as did
Dean Walter T. Sumner, from the chairmanship of the school
management committee.
Instantly teachers’ organizations, parents’ societies, the Chicago
Woman’s Club, the Woman’s City Club, and many other women’s
organizations lined up for action. A mass meeting called by them
crowded the Auditorium with 4,000 women and men on a Saturday
morning. Rousing and determined speeches were made by many
representative citizens, among whom were Jane Addams, Jenkin Lloyd
Jones, Harriet Vittum, and Margaret Haley of the Teachers’
Federation.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account