Closely following the subject of circumnavigation, the gain and loss
of time discovered on sailing east and west is referred to as another
proof of rotundity. But this illustration is equally fallacious with
the last, and from the same cause, viz., the assumption that a _globe
only_ could produce the effect observed. It will be seen, by reference
to diagram, Figure 19, that the effect must take place equally upon a
plane as upon a globe. Let the ship, W E, upon the meridian, Figure 1,
at 12 at noon, begin to sail towards the position, Figure 2, which it
will reach the next day at 12, or in 24 hours: the sun during the same
24 hours will have returned only to Figure 1, and will require to move
for another hour or more until it reaches the ship at Figure 2, making
25 hours instead of 24, in which the sun would have returned to the
ship, if it had remained at Figure 1. In this way, the sun is more and
more behind the meridian time of the ship, as it proceeds day after day
upon its westerly course, so that on completing the circumnavigation
the ship’s time is a day later than the solar time, reckoning to and
from the meridian of Greenwich. But the contrary follows if the ship
sails from Figure 1 towards Figure 4, or the east, because it will meet
the sun one hour earlier than the 24 hours which would be required for
it to pass on to Figure 1. Hence, on completing the circle 1.4.3.2.1,
the time at the ship would be one day in advance of the time at
Greenwich, or the position Figure 1. Captain Sir J. C. Ross, at page
132, vol. 2, says--“November 25, having by sailing to the eastward
gained 12 hours, it became necessary, on crossing the 180th degree and
entering upon west longitude, in order to have our time correspond with
that of England, to have two days following of the same date, and by
this means lose the time we had gained, and still were gaining, as we
sailed to the eastward.”
In further illustration of this matter, and to impress the mind of the
readers with its importance as an evidence in support of the theory
of the earth’s sphericity, several authors have given the following
story:--Two brothers, twins, born within a few minutes of each other,
and therefore of the same age, on growing to manhood went to sea. They
both circumnavigated the earth, but in opposite directions; and when
they again met, one was a day older than the other!
Whatever truth there may be in this account, it is here shown to be no
more favourable to the idea of rotundity than it is to the opposite
fact that the earth is a plane; as both forms will permit of the same
effect.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account