Zoological Illustrations, Volume 1: or, Original Figures and Descriptions of New, Rare, or Interesting AnimalsSwainson, William
Science
Zoological Illustrations, Volume 1: or, Original Figures and Descriptions of New, Rare, or Interesting Animals
Swainson, William
Animals -- Pictorial works
Whether this species is the same as the one mentioned by Temminck as
existing in the French Museum under the name of _P. flavirostris_, it is
quite impossible to say, as the description of that bird has never been
published. This leads me to notice a custom several naturalists of the
present day have lately adopted, of publishing names, and names only, of
new or undescribed animals, which they then wish to be considered as
permanently fixed, and as having thus secured to themselves all the merit
of first describing. Now this at best is but a surreptitious path to fame,
and in many instances bears the appearance of originating in a petty
vanity, quite beneath the dignity of true science: it is easily fixing a
name to an object which we have not before seen, or suspect may be new,
without the trouble of investigating authors and comparing synonyms: the
name may remain, but if it should afterwards be discovered as hasty and
erroneous, its author is in no way amenable to the opinions and criticisms
of others, for they cannot discover such mistakes when no clue is given
them beyond a name, which may frequently be applicable to half a dozen
species. If, on the other hand, the object is really new, the scientific
world is still in the dark, for without a description the name conveys
nothing. Besides this, it has a tendency to deprive those writers of their
well-earned merit, who undergo the laborious but necessary investigation of
books, the examining and comparing of specimens, and the construction of
sound characters previous to their publishing a new addition to the great
volume of Nature. Against this _scientific monopoly_ a stand should be
made, and all names either of families, genera, or species should be
totally rejected, unless their meaning is clearly defined. Let those who
run the race, receive the wreath; and not let it be snatched from the
winning-post by another, who jumps from behind and claims it as his own.
On a careful examination of my specimen, I find the nostrils are not
covered by a membrane, as observed by Temminck, but are open, obliquely and
ovately round, and a narrow rim round the margin. That excellent
ornithologist likewise remarks that the first and second quill-feathers are
the longest; but my bird (which, however, is in full plumage) has the first
and third of equal length and shorter than the second, which is longest.
These nice distinctions lead me to suppose the species from which his
generic character was taken, is distinct from this.
* * * * *
Pl. 32
[Illustration]
PSARIS Cuvierii.
_Cuvier's Psaris._
* * * * *
GENERIC CHARACTER.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account