A Moslem seeker after God : $b showing Islam at its best in the life and teaching of al-Ghazali, mystic and theologian of the eleventh century
Al-Ghazali · en
Martensen defines Christian ethics as “the science of morals conditioned
by Christianity.” But the three fundamental concepts of Christian ethics
are all of them challenged by the teaching of Islam. The Mohammedan idea
of the Highest Good, of Virtue and of the Moral Law are not in accord
with those of Christianity. This is evident both from the character of
Mohammed himself and from his recorded sayings. Ideal virtue is to be
found through imitation of Mohammed. And the moral law is practically
abrogated because of loose views as to its real character, its teaching
and finality. “The ethics of Islam bear the character of an outwardly
and crudely conceived doctrine of righteousness; conscientiousness in
the sphere of the social relations, faithfulness to conviction and to
one’s word, and the bringing of an action into relation to God, are its
bright points; but there is a lack of heart-depth, of a basing of the
moral in love. The highest good is the very outwardly and very sensuously
conceived happiness of the individual.”[66]
This statement needs no proof to those who know Islam from its
original sources, the Koran and Tradition. Professor Margoliouth uses
language which is strong but not unfair when he says in regard to the
saints of the Moslem calendar—that is the companions and followers of
Mohammed—“Those who recount the history of Islam have to lay aside all
ordinary canons of morality, else the picture would have no lights; they
could not write at all if they let themselves be shocked by perfidy or
bloodthirstiness, by cruelty or lust, yet both the Koran and Tradition
forbid the first three, and assign some limits to the fourth.” A stream
cannot rise higher than its source; a tower cannot be broader than its
foundation. The measure of the moral stature of Mohammed is the source
and foundation of all moral ideals in Islam. His conduct is the standard
of character. We need not be surprised, therefore, that the ethical
standard is so low even in Al-Ghazali, although he ofttimes rises high
above the Koran and the Prophet.
In nearly every one of his books on morals the Prophet of Arabia is held
up as the highest ideal of character. In his “Precious Pearl,” however,
there is a passage quoted from a tradition in which he pays this high
tribute to Jesus Christ (page 24, Cairo Edition), “_Go to Jesus, on Him
be peace, for He is the truest of those who were sent as apostles, and
who knew most of God, and the most ascetic in life of them all, and the
most eloquent of all in wisdom, perchance He will intercede for you._”
The quotation, however, refers to the day of resurrection when the
various nations seek God’s favour and forgiveness.