Feminism in Greek Literature from Homer to Aristotle — Aristotle — John Shaqi
Feminism in Greek Literature from Homer to Aristotle
Aristotle · en
So much then for Euripides’ men. Let us now contrast them in their
monotony of type—impute it to the poet or the sex as you will—with the
infinite variety of his women: Phædra, Andromache, Hermionë, Creüsa,
Megara, Helen, Alcestis, Clytemnestra, Medea. There is every shade
of conduct here and nearly every form of marital complication, if we
remember that none of these wives are in love with their husbands and
that romantic affection between husband and wife is impossible. They
are all—when they have children—mothers first and wives afterwards; the
childless woman—Hermionë and, apparently, Creüsa—is embittered by her
state and her conduct also is abnormal: she is anxious to take life
because she has not given life.
The poet is at pains to show the impossibility of married love under
Greek conditions. Phædra is married to an old man, who years before had
seduced her sister. Andromache has been forcibly taken by the son of the
man who slew her first husband. Hermionë has been compelled for political
reasons to give up her cousin-lover and marry a stranger. Medea after
abandoning everything for her husband is deserted by him. Creüsa has been
seduced as a girl and as a ‘pis aller’ has married an elderly man. Megara
has been abandoned by her roving husband: she and her children are on the
point of being killed by a stranger when Heracles returns and murders
them himself. Helen runs away from her lord; Clytemnestra has no words
bad enough to use of hers.
None of these women are impeccable—Alcestis is the only flawless
character and she is meant to be a saint—their tempers are as composite
as we find them in real life; but, however wrong or mistaken some of
their actions may be, not one is altogether unsympathetic. So with the
old women. They are sometimes malignant, but they are never contemptible.
Their worst deeds are prompted by maternal affection. Phædra’s
foster-mother is a mischievous and immoral old lady, but her only wish
is to gratify her foster child. Hecuba takes a ruthless vengeance on
the Thracian king, but she is a mother avenging a murdered son. It is a
favourite motive with Euripides; the pathos of the old mother, her sons
killed, her daughters ravished, her grandchildren sold into slavery.
Hecuba in the _Trojan Women_, Jocasta in the _Phœnician Women_, the
chorus of old women in the _Suppliants_: all represent the reverse side
of war’s pomp and glory. The men triumph and the women suffer. The method
is realistic: there is little romance, in the baser sense of the word, in
these unkempt, miserable, old figures, and yet they supply the poet with
some of his most poignant passages.