rivals, _Good Words_ and the _Sunday Magazine_, it is nevertheless a storehouse of good, if not of exceptionally fine, work. THE CHURCHMAN'S SHILLING MAGAZINE, A periodical of the conventional octavo size, affected by the illustrated shilling periodicals of the sixties, was commenced in 1867. The first two volumes contain little of note, and are illustrated by R. Huttula, John Leigh, E. F. C. Clarke; the third volume has M. E. Edwards, and in the fifth volume Walter Crane supplies two full pages (pp. 267, 339). Despite the fact that it credited its artists duly in the index, and seemed to have been most favourably noticed at the time, it may be dismissed here without further notice. TINSLEY'S MAGAZINE This shilling monthly was started in August 1867 with illustrations by 'Phiz,' W. Brunton, D. H. Friston, and A. W. Cooper. A. Boyd Houghton's contributions include _The Story of a Chignon_ (i. p. 544), _For the King_ (ii. p. 149), and _The Return from Court_ (ii. p. 377). J. D. Watson appears in vol. iii. pp. 87, 399, 665, and a drawing, signed A. T. (possibly Alfred Thompson), is on p. 207. But the magazine, although published at a shilling, and therefore apparently intended as a rival to the _Cornhill_ and the rest, is not important so far as its illustrations are concerned. THE BROADWAY This international magazine, heralded with much flourish in 1867 by Messrs. Routledge, is of no great importance, yet as it was illustrated from its first number in September 1867 to July 1874, it must needs be mentioned. Examples of the following artists will be found therein:--F. Barnard, G. A. Barnes, W. Brunton, M. E. Edwards, Paul Gray, E. Griset, A. B. Houghton, R. C. Huttula, F. W. Lawson, Matt Morgan, Thomas Nash, J. A. Pasquier, Alfred Thompson, and J. Gordon Thomson. SAINT PAUL'S, Yet another shilling magazine which was started in October 1867, and published by Messrs. Virtue and Co., is memorable for its twenty-two drawings by Millais. These appeared regularly to illustrate Trollope's _Phineas Finn the Irish Member_. A few illustrations by F. A. Fraser were issued to _Ralph the Heir_, the next story, and to _The Three Brothers_, but from 1871 it appears without pictures. By way of working off the long serial by Trollope, _Ralph the Heir_, independent supplements as thick as an ordinary number, but entirely filled with chapters of the story in question, were issued in April and October 1870. So curious a departure from ordinary routine is worth noting. GOOD WORDS FOR THE YOUNG,