The Philosophy of Fine Art, volume 4 (of 4): Hegel's Aesthetik — Georg Hegel — John Shaqi
The Philosophy of Fine Art, volume 4 (of 4): Hegel's Aesthetik
Georg Hegel · en
(_αα_) In this connection we may affirm of the Epos--not, however, as
is generally assumed of the drama--that _Destiny_ is a predominant
force. No doubt the dramatic character by the kind of end accepted,
which he endeavours to carry out despite all obstruction under the
circumstances given and recognized, makes of _himself_ his Destiny;
but in the Epos, on the contrary, it is _made for him_, and this force
of circumstances, which stamp their particular form on the deed,
apportions to each individual his lot, determines the result of his
actions--is, in short, the genuine control of Destiny. What happens
is appertinent to itself. It is so, and only thus; it is the fiat of
necessity. In lyric poetry we are conscious of emotion, reflection, the
personal interest, and yearning. The drama converts the ideal claim
of human action into an objective presence. The presentation of epic
poetry, on the other hand, moves, as it were, within the element itself
of essentially necessary existence. Therefore, the individual has no
choice but to follow this particular substantive condition; and, in
its process of being, to adapt himself to it or not, and then to suffer
as he is able and is forced to suffer. Destiny, in short, defines what
is and inevitably must be, and in the result success, misadventure,
life, and death are plastic precisely in the sense that individuals
are plastic. What does actually unfold before us is a condition of
universal expanse, in which the actions and destinies of mankind appear
as something isolated and evanescent. This fatality is the great
justice, and is not tragic in the dramatic sense of the term, in which
the individual appears judged as a _personality_, but in the epic sense
in which judgment is passed on man in all that concerns him.[16] The
tragic Nemesis consists in this, that the greatness of his concerns is
too great for the individual concerned. Consequently a certain tone of
sadness[17] prevails over the whole. What is most glorious is seen very
early to pass away. In the fulness of his life Achilles mourns over his
death; and at the conclusion of the Odyssey we view him and Agamemnon
as spirits that have passed away as shades, with the consciousness that
they are shades. Troy, too, falls; old Priam is slain hard by the altar
of the home; women and maidens become slaves. Æneas, in obedience to
the divine command, departs to found a new kingdom in Latium, and the
victorious heroes only return after manifold suffering to the happiness
or bitterness that awaits them at home.
(_ββ_) This necessity of events may, however, be represented in very
different ways.