The Philosophy of Fine Art, volume 4 (of 4): Hegel's Aesthetik
Georg Hegel · en
Essentially distinct from the above type of conception is the complete
interlacement of all human destiny and natural event with the
resolution, volition and action of a many-sided world of gods such
as we find in the great Hindoo Epopees, and in Homer, Virgil, and
others. I have already expressly drawn attention to the varied poetic
interpretation which the poet himself supplies of events, which are
apparently accidental, through his assumption of the co-operation and
apparition of gods, and attempted to enforce the same by particular
examples from the Iliad and the Odyssey. Here we may observe that the
condition of most importance to the poetry in question is that in this
reciprocal action of gods and men the relative independence of both
aspects is maintained, so that neither the gods fall into lifeless
abstractions, nor the human individuals become purely subservient
vassals. How such a danger is to be avoided I have already discussed
at length in a previous passage. The Hindoo Epos is in this respect
unable to force its way fully to the truly ideal relation between
gods and mankind; on such a stage of imaginative symbolism the human
aspect still remains aloof in its free and beautiful actuality, and the
activity of individuals in part appears as the incarnation of gods,
and in part, as something of more incidental merit, vanishes, or is
depicted under the guise of ascetic exaltation to the condition and
power of gods. Conversely the variously personified powers, passions,
genii, angels, and so forth, that we meet with in Christendom possess
for the most part too little individual independence, and consequently
tend only to affect us in a cold and abstract sort of way. The case is
much the same in Mohammedanism. Through the deification of Nature and
the world of mankind, through the conception of a prosaic co-ordination
of reality, it is hardly possible to avoid the danger, more
particularly where we enter a region of fairyland, wherein a miraculous
interpretation is given to that which is essentially contingent and
indifferent in external circumstances, which are themselves only
present as a simple occasion for human action and as the ordeal of
individual character, without possessing therewith an ideal consistency
and foundation. By reason of this no doubt the infinitely extensible
connection of cause and effect is broken, and the many sections in this
prosaic concatenation of circumstances, which cannot be throughout
made clearly distinct, are brought all of a sudden into one union. If,
however, such a result is secured without the principle of necessity
and ideal reasonableness, such a mode of elucidation, as, for example,
frequently in "The Thousand and one Nights," appears as little more
than the sport of an imagination, which endeavours to unfold as
causality possible and actual, by means of such inventions, what is
otherwise incredible.