The Philosophy of Fine Art, volume 4 (of 4): Hegel's Aesthetik — Georg Hegel — John Shaqi
The Philosophy of Fine Art, volume 4 (of 4): Hegel's Aesthetik
Georg Hegel · en
(_β_) A _second_ province belonging to the type under consideration
is that of the modern _opera_, in the direction, at least, which
it more and more is inclined to take. In other words, although in
opera, generally speaking, the music is of most importance, which of
course possesses a content in partnership with the poetry and the
libretto, albeit it treats and executes the same freely as it thinks
best, yet in more recent times, and particularly among ourselves,
it has become increasingly an affair of luxurious display. It has
carried its _accessoires_, in the splendour of its decorations, the
pomp of its costumes, the completeness of its choruses and their
grouping, to a degree of independence that throws all else into the
shade. It was a magnificence of this kind, sufficiently criticized
among ourselves, which Cicero long ago complains of when referring
to Roman tragedy. In tragedy, where the poetry is always the most
essential thing, such a lavish display of the sensuous side of things
is no doubt not in its right place, although Schiller, in his "Maid
of Orleans," shows a tendency here to run astray. In the opera, on
the contrary, with its sensuous exuberance of song and the melodic,
thundering chorus of voices and instruments, we may with more reason
admit such an emphasized charm of external embellishment and display.
If the decorations are splendid, then the groups and processions, to
give point to them, must be equally gorgeous, and everything else must
be adapted to the same scale. The subject most suited to a sensuous
luxuriance of this kind, which, no doubt, is always some indication
of the decline of genuine art, is that part of the entire performance
which inclines to the wonderful, fantastic, or fairy tale. Mozart, in
his "Magic Flute," has supplied us with an example which is not too
extravagant, and is worked out on completely artistic lines. At the
same time, we may entirely exhaust all the arts of scenic display,
costume, instrumentation and the rest, but the fact remains that, if we
are not really in earnest with that part of the content which concerns
real dramatic action, the impression upon us can be at the strongest
merely that of a perusal of the fairy-tale of "The Thousand and One
Nights."