The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 01 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
And seeing that from different smells there must necessarily proceed
some mutation in the organ, and all mutation is motion; it is therefore
also necessary that, in smelling, the parts of the organ, that is to say
of that internal cuticle and the nerves that are inserted into it, must
be diversely moved by different smells. And seeing also, that it hath
been demonstrated, that nothing can be moved but by a body that is
already moved and contiguous; and that there is no other body contiguous
to the internal membrane of the nostrils but breath, that is to say
attracted air, and such little solid invisible bodies, if there be any
such, as are intermingled with the air; it follows necessarily, that the
cause of smelling is either the motion of that pure air or ethereal
substance, or the motion of those small bodies. But this motion is an
effect proceeding from the object of smell, and, therefore, either the
whole object itself or its several parts must necessarily be moved. Now,
we know that odorous bodies make odour, though their whole bulk be not
moved. Wherefore the cause of odour is the motion of the invisible parts
of the odorous body. And these invisible parts do either go out of the
object, or else, retaining their former situation with the rest of the
parts, are moved together with them, that is to say, they have simple
and invisible motion. They that say, there goes something out of the
odorous body, call it an effluvium; which effluvium is either of the
ethereal substance, or of the small bodies that are intermingled with
it. But, that all variety of odours should proceed from the effluvia of
those small bodies that are intermingled with the ethereal substance, is
altogether incredible, for these considerations; first, that certain
unguents, though very little in quantity, do nevertheless send forth
very strong odours, not only to a great distance of place, but also for
a great continuance of time, and are to be smelt in every point both of
that place and time; so that the parts issued out are sufficient to fill
ten thousand times more space, than the whole odorous body is able to
fill; which is impossible. Secondly, that whether that issuing out be
with strait or with crooked motion, if the same quantity should flow
from any other odorous body with the same motion, it would follow that
all odorous bodies would yield the same smell. Thirdly, that seeing
those effluvia have great velocity of motion (as is manifest from this,
that noisome odours proceeding from caverns are presently smelt at a
great distance) it would follow, that, by reason there is nothing to
hinder the passage of those effluvia to the organ, such motion alone
were sufficient to cause smelling; which is not so; for we cannot smell
at all, unless we draw in our breath through our nostrils. Smelling,
therefore, is not caused by the effluvium of atoms; nor, for the same
reason, is it caused by the effluvium of ethereal substance; for so also