The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 03 (of 11) — Thomas Hobbes — John Shaqi
The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 03 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
But if the representative be an assembly; whatsoever that assembly shall
decree, not warranted by their letters, or the laws, is the act of the
assembly, or body politic, and the act of every one by whose vote the
decree was made; but not the act of any man that being present voted to
the contrary; nor of any man absent, unless he voted it by procuration.
It is the act of the assembly, because voted by the major part; and if
it be a crime, the assembly may be punished, as far forth as it is
capable, as by dissolution, or forfeiture of their letters (which is to
such artificial, and fictitious bodies, capital) or, if the assembly
have a common stock, wherein none of the innocent members have
propriety, by pecuniary mulct. For from corporal penalties nature hath
exempted all bodies politic. But they that gave not their vote, are
therefore innocent, because the assembly cannot represent any man in
things unwarranted by their letters, and consequently are not involved
in their votes.
[Sidenote: When the representative is one man, if he borrow money, or
owe it, by contract, he is liable only, the members not.]
If the person of the body politic being in one man, borrow money of a
stranger, that is, of one that is not of the same body, (for no letters
need limit borrowing, seeing it is left to men’s own inclinations to
limit lending), the debt is the representative’s. For if he should have
authority from his letters, to make the members pay what he borroweth,
he should have by consequence the sovereignty of them; and therefore the
grant were either void, as proceeding from error, commonly incident to
human nature, and an insufficient sign of the will of the granter; or if
it be avowed by him, then is the representer sovereign, and falleth not
under the present question, which is only of bodies subordinate. No
member therefore is obliged to pay the debt so borrowed, but the
representative himself: because he that lendeth it, being a stranger to
the letters, and to the qualification of the body, understandeth those
only for his debtors, that are engaged: and seeing the representer can
engage himself, and none else, has him only for debtor; who must
therefore pay him, out of the common stock, if there be any, or, if
there be none, out of his own estate.
If he come into debt by contract, or mulct, the case is the same.
[Sidenote: When it is an assembly, they only are liable that have
assented.]
But when the representative is an assembly, and the debt to a stranger;
all they, and only they are responsible for the debt, that gave their
votes to the borrowing of it, or to the contract that made it due, or to
the fact for which the mulct was imposed; because every one of those in
voting did engage himself for the payment: for he that is author of the
borrowing, is obliged to the payment, even of the whole debt; though
when paid by any one, he be discharged.