The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 05 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
(_k_) “And now that I have answered T. H.’s arguments drawn from the
private conceptions of men concerning the sense of words, I desire him
seriously without prejudice to examine himself, and those natural
notions which he finds in himself, (not of words, but of things; these
are from nature, those are by imposition), whether he doth not find by
experience, that he doth many things which he might have left undone if
he would, and omits many things which he might have done if he would;
whether he doth not some things out of mere animosity and will, without
either regard to the direction of right reason or serious respect of
what is honest or profitable, only to show that he will have a dominion
over his own actions; as we see ordinarily in children, and wise men
find at some times in themselves by experience; (and I apprehend this
very defence of necessity against liberty to be partly of that kind);
whether he is not angry with those who draw him from his study, or cross
him in his desires; (if they be necessitated to do it, why should he be
angry with them, any more than he is angry with a sharp winter, or a
rainy day that keeps him at home against his antecedent will?); whether
he doth not sometimes blame himself, and say, ‘O what a fool was I to do
thus and thus’, or wish to himself, ‘O that I had been wise’, or, ‘O
that I had not done such an act’. If he have no dominion over his
actions, if he be irresistibly necessitated to all things that he doth,
he might as well wish, ‘O that I had not breathed,’ or blame himself for
growing old, ‘O what a fool was I to grow old’.”
ANIMADVERSIONS UPON THE ANSWER TO NO. XXXIII.