The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 05 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
He taketh it ill that I say that arguments do seldom work on men of wit
and learning, when they have once engaged themselves in a contrary
opinion. Nevertheless it is not only certain by experience, but also
there is reason for it, and that grounded upon the natural disposition
of mankind. For it is natural to all men to defend those opinions, which
they have once publicly engaged themselves to maintain; because to have
that detected for error, which they have publicly maintained for truth,
is never without some dishonour, more or less; and to find in themselves
that they have spent a great deal of time and labour in deceiving
themselves, is so uncomfortable a thing, as it is no wonder if they
employ their wit and learning, if they have any, to make good their
errors. And, therefore, where he saith, (_a_) “solid and substantial
reasons work sooner upon them, than upon weaker judgments; and that the
more exact the balance is, the sooner it discovers the real weight that
is put into it”: I confess, the more solid a man’s wit is, the better
will solid reasons work upon him. But if he add to it that which he
calls learning, that is to say, much reading of other men’s doctrines
without weighing them with his own thoughts, then their judgments become
weaker, and the balance less exact. And whereas he saith, “that they
whose gold is true, are not afraid to have it tried by the touch”; he
speaketh as if I had been afraid to have my doctrine tried by the touch
of men of wit and learning; wherein he is not much mistaken, meaning by
men of learning (as I said before) such as had read other men, but not
themselves. For by reading others, men commonly obstruct the way to
their own exact and natural judgment, and use their wit both to deceive
themselves with fallacies, and to requite those, who endeavour at their
own entreaty to instruct them, with revilings.