The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 06 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
_A._ It is true that great rebellions have been raised by Church-men in
the Pope’s quarrel against kings, as in England against King John, and
in France against King Henry IV. Wherein the Kings had a more
considerable part on their sides, than the Pope had on his; and shall
always have so, if they have money. For there are but few whose
consciences are so tender as to refuse money when they want it. But the
great mischief done to kings upon pretence of religion is, when the Pope
gives power to one king to invade another.
_B._ I wonder how King Henry the Eighth could then so utterly extinguish
the authority of the Pope in England, and that without any rebellion at
home, or any invasion from abroad.
_A._ First, the priests, monks, and friars, being in the height of their
power, were now for the most part grown insolent and licentious; and
thereby the force of their arguments was now taken away by the scandal
of their lives, which the gentry and men of good education easily
perceived: and the Parliament consisting of such persons, were therefore
willing to take away their power: and generally the common people, which
from a long custom had been in love with Parliaments, were not
displeased therewith. Secondly, the doctrine of Luther beginning a
little before, was now by a great many men of the greatest judgment so
well received, as that there was no hope to restore the Pope to his
power by rebellion. Thirdly, the revenue of abbeys and all other
religious houses, falling thereby into the King’s hands, and by him
being disposed of to the most eminent gentlemen in every county, could
not but make them do their best to confirm themselves in the possession
of them. Fourthly, King Henry was of a nature quick and severe in the
punishing of such as should be the first to oppose his designs. Lastly,
as to invasion from abroad, in case the Pope had given the kingdom to
another prince, it had been in vain; for England is another manner of
kingdom than Navarre. Besides, the French and Spanish forces were
employed at that time one against another: and though they had been at
leisure, they would have found perhaps no better success than the
Spaniards found afterwards in 1588. Nevertheless, notwithstanding the
insolence, avarice, and hypocrisy of the then clergy, and
notwithstanding the doctrine of Luther, if the Pope had not provoked the
King by endeavouring to cross his marriage with his second wife, his
authority might have remained in England till there had risen some other
quarrel.