The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 07 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
At the seventh article, I have sufficiently demonstrated, that all
motion is infinitely propagated, as far as space is filled with body.
You allege no fault in the demonstration, but object from sense, _that
the skipping of a flea is not propagated to the Indies_. If I ask you
how you know it, you may wonder perhaps, but answer you cannot. Are you
philosophers, or geometricians, or logicians, more than are the simplest
of rural people? or are you not rather less, by as much as he that
standeth still in ignorance, is nearer to knowledge, than he that
runneth from it by erroneous learning?
And, lastly, what an absurd objection is it which you make to the eighth
article, where I say that _when two bodies of equal magnitude fall upon
a third body, that which falls with greater velocity, imprints the
greater motion_? You object, _that not so much the magnitude is to be
considered as the weight_; as if the weight made no difference in the
velocity, when notwithstanding weight is nothing else but motion
downward. Tell me, when a weighty body thrown upwards worketh on the
body it meeteth with, do you not then think it worketh the more for the
greatness, and the less for the weight.
==========
OF THE FAULTS THAT OCCUR IN
DEMONSTRATION.
TO THE SAME EGREGIOUS PROFESSORS OF THE MATHEMATICS IN
THE UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD.
LESSON IV.
Of twenty articles which you say (of nineteen which I say) make the
sixteenth chapter, you except but three, and confidently affirm the rest
are false. On the contrary, except three or four faults, such as any
geometrician may see proceed not from ignorance of the subject, or from
want of the art of demonstration, (and such as any man might have mended
of himself) but from security; I affirm that they are all true, and
truly demonstrated; and that all your objections proceed from mere
ignorance of the mathematics.
The first fault you find is this, that I express not (art. 1) what
_impetus_ it is, which I would have to be multiplied into the time.