The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 07 (of 11) — Thomas Hobbes — John Shaqi
The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 07 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
Having in the precedent lessons maintained the truth of my geometry, and
sufficiently made appear that your objections against it are but so many
errors of your own, proceeding from misunderstanding of the propositions
you have read in Euclid, and other masters of geometry; I leave it to
your consideration to whom belong, according to your own sentence, the
unhandsome attributes you so often give me upon supposition, that you
yourselves are in the right, and I mistaken; and come now to purge
myself of those greater accusations which concern my manners. It cannot
be expected that there should be much science of any kind in a man that
wanteth judgment; nor judgment in a man that knoweth not the manners due
to a public disputation in writing; wherein the scope of either party
ought to be no other than the examination and manifestation of the
truth. For whatsoever is added of contumely, either directly or
_scommatically_, is want of charity and uncivil, unless it be done by
way of reddition from him that is first provoked to it. I say unless it
be by way of reddition; for so was the judgment given by the emperor
Vespasian in a quarrel between a senator and a knight of Rome which had
given him ill language. For when the knight had proved that the first
ill language proceeded from the senator, the emperor acquitted him in
these words: “_Maledici senatoribus non oportere; remaledicere, fas et
civile esse_.” Nevertheless, now-a-days, uncivil words are commonly and
bitterly used by all that write in matter of controversy, especially in
divinity, excepting now and then such writers as have been more than
ordinarily well bred, and have observed how heinous and hazardous a
thing such contumely is amongst some sorts of men, whether that which is
said in disgrace be true or false. For evil words by all men of
understanding are taken for a defiance, and a challenge to open war. But
that you should have observed so much, who are yet in your mother’s
belly, was not a thing to be much expected.