Philosophumena; or, The refutation of all heresies, Volume I — David Hume — John Shaqi
Philosophumena; or, The refutation of all heresies, Volume I
David Hume · en
But all this will for most of us yield in interest to the picture
which our text gives us of the struggles of Christianity against its
external and internal foes during the first three centuries. So far
from this period having been one of quiet growth and development for
the infant Church, we see her in Hippolytus’ pages exposed not only to
fierce if sporadic persecution from pagan emperors, but also to the
steady and persistent rivalry of scores of competing schools led by
some of the greatest minds of the age, and all combining some of the
main tenets of Christianity with the relics of heathenism. We now know,
too, that she was not always able to present an unbroken front to these
violent or insidious assailants. In the highest seats of the Church,
as we now learn for the first time, there were divisions on matters of
faith which anticipated in some measure those which nearly rent her
in twain after the promulgation of the Creed of Nicæa. Such a schism
as that between the churches of Hippolytus and Callistus must have
given many an opportunity to those foes who were in some sort of her
own household; while round the contest, like the irregular auxiliaries
of a regular army, swarmed a crowd of wonder-workers, diviners, and
other exploiters of the public credulity, of whose doings we have
before gained some insight from writers like Lucian and Apuleius, but
whose methods and practices are for the first time fully described by
Hippolytus.
The conversion of the whole Empire under Constantine broke once for all
the power of these enemies of the Church. Schisms were still to occur,
but grievous as they were, they happily proved impotent to destroy the
essential unity of Christendom. The heathen faiths and the Gnostic
sects derived from them were soon to wither like plants that had no
root, and both they and the charlatans whose doings our author details
were relentlessly hunted down by the State which had once given them
shelter: while if the means used for this purpose were not such as the
purer Christian ethics would now approve, we must remember that these
means would probably have proved ineffective had not Christian teaching
already destroyed the hold of these older beliefs on the seething
populations of the Empire. That the adolescent Church should thus have
been enabled to triumph over all her enemies may seem to many a better
proof of her divine guidance than the miraculous powers once attributed
to her. We may not all of us be able to believe that a rainstorm put
out the fire on which Thekla was to be burned alive, or that the
crocodiles in the tank in the arena into which she was cast were struck
by lightning and floated to the surface dead.[91] Still less can we
credit that the portraits of St. Theodore and other military saints
left their place in the palace of the Queen of Persia and walked about
in human form.[92] Such stories are for the most of us either pious
fables composed for edification or half-forgotten records of natural