Philosophumena; or, The refutation of all heresies, Volume II
David Hume · en
6. Now having brought together the teachings of all the sages among
[the] Greeks in four books,[5] and those of the heresiarchs in
five, we shall point out the Doctrine concerning the Truth in one,
after having first made a summary of what has been the opinions of
all. For the teachers of the Greeks, dividing philosophy into three
parts, so philosophize, some preaching Physics, some Ethics and some
Dialectic.[6] And those who preached Physics thus declared, some that
all things were born from one, others from many. And of those who
said [they came] from one, some [said they came] from what had no
Quality, and others from that which had Quality. And of those who [said
they came] from that which had Quality, some [said that they came]
[Sidenote: p. 476.] from fire, others from air, others from water and
yet others from earth. And of those who [said they came forth] from
many things, some [said that they came] from numerable things [others
from boundless ones. And of those who said they came from numerable
things], some [say that they came] from two, others from four, others
from five, and others from six. And of those [who say] that they came
from the boundless things, some [say that they came] from things like
generated things, others from those unlike. And some of them say that
they came from things impassible, others from things passible. The
Stoics indeed would establish the birth of the universals from that
which has no Quality and one body. For according to them, matter
unqualified and capable of change by means of the universals is their
source. And when it is transformed, fire, air, water and earth come
into being. And those who will have all things to come into being from
that which has Quality are the followers of Hippasus and Anaximander
and Thales the Milesian. Hippasus the Metapontian[7] and Heraclitus
the Ephesian declared the genesis of things to be from fire, but
Anaximander from air, Thales from water, and Xenophanes from earth.
“For all things [came forth] from earth and all end in earth.”[8]
[Sidenote: p. 477.] 7. Of those who would derive the universals from
[the] many and [the] numerable, the poet Homer declares that the
universals have been composed of earth and water when he says:--
“Ocean source of Gods and mother Tethys.”[9]
and again:--
“But turn ye all to water and earth.”[10]
And Xenophanes the Colophonian seems to agree with him, for he says:--
“All we are sprung from earth and water.”[11]
But Euripides says from earth and aether, as he lets us see from his
saying:--
“I sing aether and earth, mother of all.”[12]
But Empedocles from four, saying thus:--
[Sidenote: p. 478.] “Hear first the four roots of all things;
Shining Zeus and life-bearing Here and Aïdoneus
And Nestis who wets with tears the human source.”