Philosophumena; or, The refutation of all heresies, Volume II
David Hume · en
But from five, Ocellus the Lucanian[13] and Aristotle. For with the
four elements they include the fifth and rotating body whence, they
say, are all heavenly things. But from six, the followers of Empedocles
derived the birth of all things. For in the verses where he says:--
“Hear first the four roots of all things”
he makes everything come from four. But when he adds to this:--
“And baleful Strife apart from these [and] equal everywhere,
And Love with them equal in length and breadth,”[14]
he is handing down six things as sources of the universals [_i. e._]
four material: earth, water, fire, [and] air and two, [Sidenote: p.
479.] the agents Love and Strife. But the followers of Anaxagoras the
Clazomenian and Democritus and Epicurus and very many others whose
[opinions] we have before recorded in part, taught that the genesis
of all things was from the boundless. But Anaxagoras says they came
from things like those produced; but the followers of Democritus and
Epicurus, from those unlike and impassible, that is from the atoms;
and those of Heraclides the Pontian[15] and Asclepiades[16] from those
which are unlike, but passible, such as disconnected corpuscles.
But the followers of Plato say that they came from three, and that
these are God, Matter and Exemplar; but he divides matter into four
principles: fire, water, earth, air; and says that God is the Demiurge
of Matter, but Exemplar the Mind.
8. Now, having been persuaded that the system of Natural Science[17] is
confessedly found unworkable by all these [philosophers], we ourselves
shall unhesitatingly say concerning the examples of the Truth what they
are and how we believe in them. But in addition we will first set forth
in epitome the [opinions] of the heresiarchs, so that [Sidenote: p.
480.] the opinions of all being thereby easy to discern, we may display
the Truth as clear and easy to discern also.
1. _Naassenes._
9. But since this seems fitting, we will begin first with the
ministers of the serpent. The Naassenes call the first principle of
the universals a man and also Son of Man,[18] and him they divide into
three. For part of him, they say, is intellectual, part psychic, and
part earthly. And they call him Adamas and think the knowledge of him
is the beginning of the power to know God. And they say that all these
intellectual and psychic and earthly [parts] came into Jesus, and that
the three substances spoke together through Him to the three races of
the All. Thus they declare that there are three races, [the] angelic,
psychic [and] earthly, and that there are three Churches, angelic,
psychic and earthly; but that their names are [the] Called, Chosen,
[and] Captive. These are the heads of their doctrine in so far as it
can be briefly comprehended. They [Sidenote: p. 481.] say that they
were handed down by James the Brother of the Lord to Mariamne, thereby
belying both.[19]
2. _Peratæ._