The History of England in Three Volumes, Vol. I., Part C.: From Henry VII. to Mary
David Hume · en
The favorers of the ancient religion maintained, on the other hand, that
the pretence of making the people see with their own eyes was a mere
cheat, and was itself a very gross artifice, by which the new preachers
hoped to obtain the guidance of them, and to seduce them from those
pastors whom the laws, whom ancient establishments, whom Heaven itself,
had appointed for their spiritual direction: that the people were by
their ignorance, their stupidity, their necessary avocations, totally
unqualified to choose their own principles; and it was a mockery to set
materials before them, of which they could not possibly make any proper
use: that even in the affairs of common life, and in their temporal
concerns, which lay more within the compass of human reason, the laws
had in a great measure deprived them of the right of private judgment,
and had, happily for their own and the public interest, regulated their
conduct and behavior: that theological questions were placed far beyond
the sphere of vulgar comprehension; and ecclesiastics themselves, though
assisted by all the advantages of education, erudition, and an assiduous
study of the science, could not be fully assured of a just decision,
except by the promise made them in Scripture, that God would be ever
present with his church, and that the gates of hell should not prevail
against her: that the gross errors adopted by the wisest heathens,
proved how unfit men were to grope their own way through this profound
darkness; nor would the Scriptures, if trusted to every man’s judgment,
be able to remedy; on the contrary, they would much augment, those fatal
illusions: that sacred writ itself was involved in so much obscurity,
gave rise to so many difficulties, contained so many appearing
contradictions, that it was the most dangerous weapon that could be
intrusted into the hands of the ignorant and giddy multitude: that the
poetical style in which a great part of it was composed, at the same
time that it occasioned uncertainty in the sense, by its multiplied
tropes and figures, was sufficient to kindle the zeal of fanaticism,
and thereby throw civil society into the most furious combustion: that a
thousand sects must arise, which would pretend, each of them, to derive
its tenets from the Scripture; and would be able, by specious arguments,
or even without specious arguments, to seduce silly women and ignorant
mechanics into a belief of the most monstrous principles: and that if
ever this disorder, dangerous to the magistrate himself, received a
remedy, it must be from the tacit acquiescence of the people in some
new authority; and it was evidently better, without further contest or
inquiry, to adhere peaceably to ancient, and therefore the more secure
establishments.