The Piccadilly Puzzle: A Mysterious Story — David Hume — John Shaqi
The Piccadilly Puzzle: A Mysterious Story
David Hume · en
The time of the discovery of the body by Mr. Ellersby was about
half-past two--the medical evidence at the inquest was to the effect
that the deceased had been dead about two hours, so allowing a margin
for possible inaccuracies the crime must have been committed about
midnight, at which time there would be a certain amount of traffic
through Jermyn Street. But then the spectacle of a man talking to a
woman in the doorway of a house would hardly attract much attention,
and if the murderer had accomplished his purpose by means of poison
there was no doubt the fanciful description given by _Hash_ would be
tolerably correct. Supposing the assassin to have wounded his victim
by means of a poisoned weapon, she would have become confused and
giddy, finally passing into a comatose state, in which she would
quietly expire. Therefore, there would be no screaming to attract the
attention of passers-by, and albeit in any case lying down would have
aroused curiosity, yet the fog was so thick on that night that no one
would see the position of the criminal and his victim.
Now, the next question was why did Miss Sarschine not make inquiries
after her maid--a week had elapsed since the murder, and the girl's
absence for that time would certainly seem unaccountable. On her
non-appearance her mistress would watch the papers to see if anything
had happened to her. She would then notice the Jermyn Street murder,
and from the description given would have no difficulty in recognizing
her servant. Since though she had without doubt become cognisant of
the fact that Lydia Fenny was dead she had not come forward to
identify the body, and Dowker pondered over the reason she had for
this reticence.
"She can't have committed the crime herself," said Dowker in a puzzled
tone, "as she would hardly do so in such a public place, but why has
she been so quiet?--again she couldn't know anything about poisoned
weapons--no, she must have some other reason for holding her tongue."
At this moment his attention was caught by the display of weapons on
the wall, and with a short exclamation he walked across the room and
looked sharply at them. They were arranged in a fantastic pattern,
each side being the same, but here Dowker noticed with much curiosity
that one side was incomplete, a Malay kriss having been removed. He
looked at the other side and there were certainly two arranged
crossways, but on the other there was only one. Dowker was startled by
this discovery as it seemed to point to the fact that the crime had
been committed by the missing kriss. He knew the Malays were a savage
nation, and without doubt poisoned their daggers, so the absence of
one of these would argue that this had been the weapon used. He
gingerly touched the point of a kriss with the tip of his finger, and
then drew it hastily away.
"It might be poisoned," he muttered, looking at his finger to assure
himself he had not broken the skin. "I wonder if it is--I'd like to
find out."