Nor are we to condemn the practice in deference to the opinion of
Hannibal, who, at the battle of Cannæ, on seeing the consuls make the
horsemen dismount, said scoffingly, “_Better still had they delivered
their knights to me in chains._” For though this saying came from the
mouth of a most excellent soldier, still, if we are to regard
authority, we ought rather to follow the authority of a commonwealth
like Rome, and of the many great captains who served her, than that of
Hannibal alone. But, apart from authority, there are manifest reasons
to bear out what I say. For a man may go on foot into many places where
a horse cannot go; men can be taught to keep rank, and if thrown into
disorder to recover form; whereas, it is difficult to keep horses in
line, and impossible if once they be thrown into disorder to reform
them. Moreover we find that with horses as with men, some have little
courage and some much; and that often a spirited horse is ridden by a
faint-hearted rider, or a dull horse by a courageous rider, and that in
whatever way such disparity is caused, confusion and disorder result.
Again, infantry, when drawn up in column, can easily break and is not
easily broken by cavalry. This is vouched, not only by many ancient and
many modern instances, but also by the authority of those who lay down
rules for the government of States, who show that at first wars were
carried on by mounted soldiers, because the methods for arraying
infantry were not yet understood, but that so soon as these were
discovered, the superiority of foot over horse was at once recognized.
In saying this, I would not have it supposed that horsemen are not of
the greatest use in armies, whether for purposes of observation, for
harrying and laying waste the enemy’s country, for pursuing a
retreating foe or helping to repulse his cavalry. But the substance and
sinew of an army, and that part of it which ought constantly to be most
considered, should always be the infantry. And among sins of the
Italian princes who have made their country the slave of foreigners,
there is none worse than that they have held these arms in contempt,
and turned their whole attention to mounted troops.