Camilla: A Tale of a Violin: Being the Artist Life of Camilla Urso
John Stuart Mill · en
The three chief numbers of this fine programme were a trio in
C-minor, op. 102, by Raff; a sonata in F-major, No. 9, by
Mozart; and Schubert’s posthumous quartette in D-minor. The Raff
trio was new to Boston. It is a long and elaborate work, the
absolute merit of which is not to be pronounced upon after a
single hearing. That it is startlingly brilliant and striking in
at least two of its numbers is plain at once, however; and there
can be no denying or doubting its great vigor and originality.
The _scherzo_ has remarkable ingenuity in its harmonic forms and
instrumental combinations; and the _andante_, amazing in its
melodic variety and richness, and reflecting, apparently, many
moods of the composer’s mind, yet produces a unity of impression
which proves the presence of a strong and self-poised genius.
The Mozart sonata for violin and piano is exceedingly
interesting in all its three movements, light and airy in its
general character,—except in the _andante_, which is touched
with pensiveness,—and not striking very far down in its
suggestions, but full of fresh beauty and consummate in its
symmetrical grace. In the happiest contrast with the sonata was
the wonderful D-minor quartette of Schubert. No better
illustration of the marked divergence between the modes of
expression natural to two master composers could have been
chosen than these. The invariable law of Mozart’s genius—in
spite of, or perhaps, in aid of its broad inclusiveness—is
condensation or conciseness; of Schubert’s, it is expansion and
diffusiveness. But where the genius is so vital and inspiring as
that which shines in every line of the D-minor quartette, the
amplitude never degenerates into tediousness. There may be
profusion in the host’s providing, but no surfeit in the guest’s
appetite.