Curiosities of Medical Experience — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Curiosities of Medical Experience
John Stuart Mill · en
The choice between shooting and hanging may be accounted for on the same
grounds. A young man, in a fit of frantic passion, from disappointed love,
or losses at play, will probably, on his return home, seize a pistol and
blow out his brains; whereas hanging needs reflection and some preparation
and precaution, which would alone suffice to bring a reflective creature
to a proper sense of his folly, unless predetermined to destroy himself by
"philosophic suicide."
It appears in these accounts that suicide in France has greatly increased
since the revolution. The average number during the last forty-two years
being 409-5/6, the number in Paris being 1639 annually. Dr. Schlegel
informs us that there exists a society in Paris called, "Society of the
Friends of Suicide." It consists of twelve members, and a lot is cast
annually to decide which of them is to destroy himself in the presence of
the others. Certain qualifications and testimonials were required before a
candidate could be admitted into this amiable club:
1. He must prove himself a man of honour.
2. He must have experienced the injustice of mankind, been injured by a
dear friend, or betrayed by a mistress or a wife.
3. He must have experienced, for some considerable time, a miserable
vacuity of soul, and a discontent with every thing in the world.
This association reminds me of a ball that was established in Paris after
the reign of terror, called _Le Bal des Victimes_, to which no person
could be admitted unless they had had a near relation guillotined.
Dr. Schlegel has also given the following statistical table of the
proportion of suicides to various populations--both as regarding counties
and principal cities:
_Countries._ _Proportion of suicides to population._
Sweden 1 in 92,375
The Milanais 1 ... 72,570
Russia, 1819-1820 1 ... 36,860
---- 1824-1827 1 ... 34,246
Prussia 1 ... 14,224
Saxony 1 ... 8,446
St. Petersburg 1 ... 416
London, 18th century 1 ... 10,572
---- 19th century 1 ... 21,491
Paris 1 ... 2,215
Geneva 1 ... 3,714
Berlin, 1788-1797 1 ... 23,066
---- 1798-1807 1 ... 12,917
---- 1813-1822 1 ... 3,312
Hamburg 1 ... 4,800
Leipzig 1 ... 3,143
Milan 1 ... 1,821
Naples 1 ... 27,230
New York 1 ... 9,474
Baltimore 1 ... 15,696
Philadelphia 1 ... 20,000