Mysterious Psychic Forces: An Account of the Author's Investigations in Psychical Research, Together with Those of Other European Savants
John Stuart Mill · en
Fraud and muscular action! Here for instance is a fine opportunity to
put them to the proof. We have just placed a weight on the table. This
weight is inert and cannot be accessory to any device. Fraud is all
around it perhaps, but it is not in the tubs of sand. This weight is
equally divided among the three legs of the table, and they are going
to prove it by each one rising in turn. The total load weighs 165
pounds, and we scarcely dare to increase it, for, as it is, it was
enough, one day, to break our very solid table. Very well; now let
someone try to move this weight. Since muscular action and fraud must
explain everything, it will be easy for them to put the mass in
motion. Now they cannot do it. Their fingers contract and the knuckles
whiten without their obtaining a single levitation, whereas, some
moments later, levitations will take place at the touch of the same
fingers, which gently graze the table's top and make no effort at all,
as any one may easily convince himself.
Certain very ingenious scientific rules of measurement, for the
invention of which I cannot claim the credit, put us in the way of
translating into figures the effort which the rotation or levitation
of the table demands, when loaded in the way just described. With the
above-mentioned weight of 165 pounds, rotation is secured by means of
a lateral traction of about 17-1/2 pounds, while levitation is only
obtained by a perpendicular pressure of 132 pounds at least (which I
will reduce, however, to 110, in deference to the presumed wishes of
the critic, and on the supposition that the pressure might not be
absolutely vertical). Several deductions are to be drawn from these
figures.
In the first place, muscular action may cause the table to turn, but
it cannot lift it. As a matter of fact, the ten operators have one
hundred fingers applied to its surface. Now, the vertical, or
quasi-vertical, pressure of each finger cannot exceed twelve ounces on
the average, the chain being composed as it is. They only develop,
then, a total pressure of 66 pounds, which is quite insufficient to
produce levitation.
In the next place, this striking thing befalls, that the phenomenon
which muscular action could easily produce is precisely the one that
we most rarely and with the greatest difficulty obtain, and that the
phenomenon which muscular action could not compass is the one the most
habitually realized when the chain is formed. Why does not our
involuntary impulse always make the table turn? Why should not our
"fraud" always procure such a triumph? Why, as a general thing, do we
only succeed in effecting that which is mechanically impossible?