Mysterious Psychic Forces: An Account of the Author's Investigations in Psychical Research, Together with Those of Other European Savants
John Stuart Mill · en
_Third principle: The substance upon which the mind immediately
acts--the psychode--is only susceptible of very simple modifications
under the influence of the mind_, for, since the movements are to be
somewhat varied, an extensive and complicated apparatus appears in the
organism,--a whole system of muscles, vessels, nerves, etc., which are
wanting in the inferior animals (among whom movements are very
simple), and which would have been unnecessary had matter been
directly susceptible of modifications equally varied under the
influence of mind. When movements are intended to be very simple (as
in the case of infusoria) the complicated apparatus is wanting and the
life-spirit acts upon matter that is almost homogeneous.
The following four hypotheses regarding the psychode may be formed:
_a._ The psychode is a substance peculiar to the organism, and not
capable of emerging from it. It acts only mediately upon everything
outside of the visible organism.
_b._ The psychode is a substance peculiar to the organism, capable of
extending beyond the limits of the visible organism under certain
special conditions. The modifications it receives necessarily act upon
other inert bodies. The will acts upon the psychode, and thus
mediately, upon the bodies that the sphere of this substance embraces.
_c._ The psychode is a universal substance which is conditioned in its
action on other inert bodies by the structure of living organisms, or
by a certain state of inorganic bodies--a state determined by the
influence of living organisms in certain special conditions.
_d._ The psychode is a peculiar state of matter, a state habitually
produced within the sphere of the organism, but which may also be
produced beyond its limits under the influence of a certain state of
the organism,--an influence comparable to that of magnets in the
phenomena of diamagnetism.
Thury proposes the adjective _ecteneic_ (from [Greek: ekteneia],
extension) to describe that special state of the organism in which the
mind can, in some measure, extend the habitual limits of its action, and
he styles "ecteneic force" that which is developed in this state.
The first hypothesis (he adds) would not be at all adapted to explain
the phenomena with which we are concerned. But the three others give
rise to three different explanations, in which (he assures us) the
greater part of the phenomena investigated will be comprised.
_Explanations based upon the Intervention of Spirits._--M. de Gasparin
has shown the error of all these explanations:
1. By theological considerations.
2. By the very just remark that we should not resort to explanations
which introduce spirits into the problem until other interpretations
have been proved to be entirely insufficient.
3. Finally, by physical considerations.