The electron, its isolation and measurement and the determination of some of its properties
John Stuart Mill · en
In view, however, of the four sets of facts mentioned above, Thomson
found it altogether impossible to go back to the old and exploded
form of corpuscular theory for an explanation of the new facts as
to the emission of electrons under the influence of ether waves. He
accordingly attempted to reconcile these troublesome new facts with the
wave theory by assuming a fibrous structure in the ether and picturing
all electromagnetic energy as traveling along Faraday lines of force
[Pg 237]
conceived of as actual strings extending through all space. Although
this concept, which we shall call the ether-string theory, is like the
corpuscular theory in that the energy, after it leaves the emitting
body, remains localized in space, and, when absorbed, is absorbed as a
whole, yet it is after all essentially an ether theory. For in it the
speed of propagation is determined by the properties of the medium—or
of space, if one prefers a mere change in name;—and has nothing to do
with the nature or condition of the source. Thus the last three of the
fatal objections to a corpuscular theory are not here encountered. As
to the first one, no one has yet shown that Thomson’s suggestion is
reconcilable with the facts of interference, though so far as I know
neither has its irreconcilability been as yet absolutely demonstrated.
But interference aside, all is not simple and easy for Thomson’s
theory. For one encounters serious difficulties when he attempts to
visualize the universe as an infinite cobweb whose threads never become
tangled or broken however swiftly the electrical charges to which they
are attached may be flying about.
III. EINSTEIN’S QUANTUM THEORY OF RADIATION
Yet the boldness and the difficulties of Thomson’s “ether-string”
theory did not deter Einstein[167] in 1905 from making it even more
radical. In order to connect it up with some results to which Planck
of Berlin had been led in studying the facts of black-body radiation,
Einstein assumed that the energy emitted by any radiator not only kept
together in bunches or quanta as it traveled through space, as Thomson
[Pg 238]
had assumed it to do, but that a given source could emit and absorb
radiant energy only in units which are all exactly equal to ,
being the natural frequency of the emitter and a constant
which is the same for all emitters.
I shall not attempt to present the basis for such an assumption, for,
as a matter of fact, it had almost none at the time. But whatever
its basis, it enabled Einstein to predict at once that the energy of
emission of electrons under the influence of light would be governed by
the equation