The Foot-prints of the Creator : $b or, The Asterolepis of Stromness
John Stuart Mill · en
of Cuvier,—a shrewd corroboration, in both cases, I am disposed to
think, of the rectitude of the arrangement. What seems to be the special
defect of his system is, that having erected his four orders, and then
finding a certain number of residuary families that, on his principle
of cuticular character, stubbornly refused to fall into any determinate
place, he distributed them among the others, with reference chiefly to
the totally distinct principle of Cuvier. Thus the _Suctorii_, soft,
smooth, slimy-skinned fishes, that do not possess a single placoid
character, and are not true Placoids, he has yet placed in his Placoid
order, influenced, apparently, by the “perception of resemblance that
has _cartilage_ for its central idea;” and the effect has been a massing
into one anomalous and entangled group the fishes of the first period
of geologic history, with fishes of which we do not find a trace save
in the existing scene of things, and of the highest families of their
class with families that occupy the lowest place. But we live in an age
in which even the benefactors of the world of mind cannot make false
steps with impunity; and so, while Agassiz’s _three_ ichthyic orders will
continue to be recognized by the palæontologist as the orders of three
great geologic periods, the _Suctorii_ have already been struck from off
his higher fishes by the classification of Muller and Owen, and carried
to that lowest point in the scale (indicated by Linnæus and Oken) which
their inferior standing renders so obviously the natural one. Some of
my readers may perhaps remember how finely Bacon, in his “Wisdom of the
Ancients,” interprets the old mythologic story of Prometheus. Prometheus,
says the philosopher, had conferred inestimable favors on men, by
moulding their forms into shape, and bringing them fire from heaven; and
yet they complained of him and his teachings to Jupiter. And the god,
instead of censuring their ingratitude, was pleased with the complaint,
and rewarded them with gifts. In putting nature to the question, it is
eminently wholesome to be doubting, cross-examining, complaining; ever
demanding of our masters and benefactors the philosophers, that they
should reign over us, not arbitrarily and despotically,
“Like the old kings, with high exacting looks,
Sceptred and globed,”
but like our modern constitutional monarchs, who govern by law; and,
further, that an appeal from their decisions on all subjects within the
jurisdiction of Nature should for ever be open to Nature herself. The
seeming ingratitude of such a course, if the “complaints” be made in a
right spirit and on proper grounds, Jupiter always rewards with gifts.