The Foot-prints of the Creator : $b or, The Asterolepis of Stromness
John Stuart Mill · en
As, however, the succession of remains in the fossiliferous series of
rocks is infinitely less favorable to the development hypothesis than
that of the organisms of the ditch-side, it is not very surprising
that the disciples of the development school should be now evincing a
disposition to escape from the ascertained facts of Geology, and the
legitimate conclusions based upon these, unto unknown and unexplored
provinces of the science; or that they should be found virtually urging,
that though some of the ascertained facts may seem to bear against them,
the facts not yet ascertained may be found telling in their favor.
Such, in effect, is the course taken by the author of the “Vestiges,”
in his “Explanations,” when, availing himself of a difference of
opinion which exists among some of our most accomplished geologists
regarding the first epochs of organized existence, he takes part with
the section who hold that we have not yet penetrated to the deposits
representative of the dawn of being, and that fossil-charged formations
may yet be detected beneath the oldest rocks of what is now regarded
as the lowest fossiliferous system. Sir Charles Lyell and Mr. Leonard
Hornet represent the abler and better-known assertors of this last view;
while Sir Roderick Murchison and Professor Sedgwick rank among the more
distinguished assertors of the antagonist one. It would be of course
utterly presumptuous in the writer of these pages to attempt deciding
a question regarding which such men differ; but in forming a judgment
for myself, various considerations incline me to hold, that the point
is now very nearly determined at which, to employ the language of Sir
Roderick, “life was first breathed into the waters.” The pyramid of
organized existence, as it ascends in the by-past eternity, inclines
sensibly towards its apex,—that apex of “_beginning_” in which, on
far other than geological grounds, it is our privilege to believe.
The broad base of the superstructure, planted on the existing _now_,
stretches across the entire scale of life, animal and vegetable; but it
contracts as it rises into the past;—man—the quadrumana—the quadrupedal
mammal—the bird—and the reptile—are each in succession struck from off
its breadth, till we at length see it with the vertebrata, represented
by only the fish, narrowing, as it were, to a point; and though the
clouds of the upper region may hide its extreme apex, we infer from the
declination of its sides, that it cannot penetrate much farther into the
profound. When Steele and Addison were engaged in breaking up, piecemeal,
their Spectator Club,—killing off good Sir Roger de Coverly with a
defluction, marrying Will Honeycomb to his tenant’s daughter, and sending
away Captain Sentry and Sir Andrew Freeport to their estates to the
country,—it was shrewdly inferred that the “Spectator” himself was very
soon to quit the field; and the sudden discontinuance of his lucubrations
justified the inference.